Tips from Other Journals

Clinical Detection of Left-Sided Heart Failure

Am Fam Physician. 1998 Mar 1;57(5):1104-1107.

The diagnosis and management of left-sided heart failure can be difficult. Badgett and associates reviewed the literature to assess how well clinicians diagnose this condition clinically and to identify clinical findings that may signify decreased ejection fraction, increased filling pressure and systolic or diastolic dysfunction.

Since left-sided heart failure can be defined as decreased ejection fraction or increased filling pressure, patients may fit into one of three categories: those with decreased ejection fraction and normal filling pressure, those with decreased ejection fraction and increased filling pressure, and those with normal ejection fraction and increased filling pressure (diastolic dysfunction). A MEDLINE search was conducted, and 34 studies were found that examined the ability of the clinical findings or clinical examination to predict filling pressure or ejection fraction. Clinical findings were classified as “very helpful,” “somewhat helpful” or “helpful only when present” (see the accompanying table).

Clinical Findings Helpful in the Detection of Heart Failure

Helpfulness of the findings Increased filling pressure Ejection fraction <40% Diastolic dysfunction

Very helpful findings*

Radiographic redistribution, jugular venous distention

Radiographic cardiomegaly, or redistribution, anterior Q waves, left bundle branch block, abnormal apical impulse

Current hypertension†

Somewhat helpful findings‡

Dyspnea, § orthopnea, tachycardia,∥ low SBP,∥ PPP <25%, S3, rales, abnormal abdominojugular reflux, radiographic cardiomegaly¶

Pulse >90, or >100 bpm, SBP <90 mm Hg, PPP <33%, S3, rales, dyspnea, any previous infarction, CPK >200 or >1,000 IU

Obesity,§ no tachycardia,§∥ elderly,∥ no smoking, no coronary disease

Findings helpful only when present#

Edema

Jugular venous distention, edema

Normal radiographic heart size


SBP = systolic blood pressure; bpm = beats per minute; PPP = proportional pulse pressure (pulse pressure/systolic pressure); S3 = third heart sound; CPK = creatine phosphokinase in postinfarction patient.

*—Very helpful findings are significant in all studies and have been studied at least twice. The findings of radiographic cardiomegaly or current hypertension are always independently significant.

†—Current hypertension is defined as systolic pressure >160 mm Hg or diastolic pressure >100 mm Hg or >105 mm Hg.

‡—Somewhat helpful findings are significant in at least one half of studies. For systolic dysfunction, only findings significant in over one half of studies are listed.

§—Only studied once.

∥—No cutoff to define abnormal.

¶—Cardiomegaly is somewhat helpful in initially detecting increased filling pressure. However, cardiomegaly may remain after reduction of the filling pressure.

#—Findings helpful only when present are consistently reported as highly specific, although they are not usually statistically significant.

Reprinted with permission from Badgett RG, Lucey CR, Mulrow CD. Can the clinical examination diagnose left-sided heart failure in adults? JAMA 1997;277:1712-9.

Clinical Findings Helpful in the Detection of Heart Failure

View Table

Clinical Findings Helpful in the Detection of Heart Failure

Helpfulness of the findings Increased filling pressure Ejection fraction <40% Diastolic dysfunction

Very helpful findings*

Radiographic redistribution, jugular venous distention

Radiographic cardiomegaly, or redistribution, anterior Q waves, left bundle branch block, abnormal apical impulse

Current hypertension†

Somewhat helpful findings‡

Dyspnea, § orthopnea, tachycardia,∥ low SBP,∥ PPP <25%, S3, rales, abnormal abdominojugular reflux, radiographic cardiomegaly¶

Pulse >90, or >100 bpm, SBP <90 mm Hg, PPP <33%, S3, rales, dyspnea, any previous infarction, CPK >200 or >1,000 IU

Obesity,§ no tachycardia,§∥ elderly,∥ no smoking, no coronary disease

Findings helpful only when present#

Edema

Jugular venous distention, edema

Normal radiographic heart size


SBP = systolic blood pressure; bpm = beats per minute; PPP = proportional pulse pressure (pulse pressure/systolic pressure); S3 = third heart sound; CPK = creatine phosphokinase in postinfarction patient.

*—Very helpful findings are significant in all studies and have been studied at least twice. The findings of radiographic cardiomegaly or current hypertension are always independently significant.

†—Current hypertension is defined as systolic pressure >160 mm Hg or diastolic pressure >100 mm Hg or >105 mm Hg.

‡—Somewhat helpful findings are significant in at least one half of studies. For systolic dysfunction, only findings significant in over one half of studies are listed.

§—Only studied once.

∥—No cutoff to define abnormal.

¶—Cardiomegaly is somewhat helpful in initially detecting increased filling pressure. However, cardiomegaly may remain after reduction of the filling pressure.

#—Findings helpful only when present are consistently reported as highly specific, although they are not usually statistically significant.

Reprinted with permission from Badgett RG, Lucey CR, Mulrow CD. Can the clinical examination diagnose left-sided heart failure in adults? JAMA 1997;277:1712-9.

The diagnosis of increased left ventricular filling pressure cannot be made on the basis of a single clinical finding. Radiographic redistribution (also known as cephalization or pulmonary venous hypertension) and jugular venous distention were found to be very helpful findings but are best used to confirm increased filling pressure in a patient with known severe systolic dysfunction. Lack of radiographic redistribution or jugular venous distention, however, does not exclude increased filling pressure. Dyspnea and abnormal vital signs were found to be somewhat helpful in the detection of increased filling pressure. Dependent edema was helpful in making the diagnosis only when present.

Since the detection of increased filling pressure is difficult, the authors suggest that the number of abnormal findings on examination may correlate with a probability of increased filling pressure. In the absence of known severe systolic dysfunction, patients with no more than one abnormal finding are likely to have a normal filling pressure, whereas those with at least three abnormal findings may have increased filling pressure.

Certain clinical findings may help identify patients with an ejection fraction of less than 40 percent. These findings are as follows: cardiomegaly (radiographically determined), abnormal apical impulse, radiographic redistribution, left bundle branch block and anterior Q waves. Tachycardia, decreased blood pressure and a third heart sound may be somewhat helpful findings. Insignificant clinical findings include the patient's age, orthopnea, left ventricular hypertrophy, a history of hypertension and a history of heart failure. Again, patients may be classified as having a high, an indeterminate or a low probability of decreased ejection fraction. A decreased ejection fraction is much more likely if three or more abnormal clinical findings are present. Patients with a low probability of decreased ejection fraction have none of the abnormal clinical findings associated with a decreased ejection fraction.

Distinguishing between diastolic and systolic dysfunction may be aided by the finding of elevated blood pressure during an episode of increased filling pressure. Obesity, lack of tachycardia, absence of smoking and no history of coronary artery disease may be somewhat helpful findings. Patients with a normal heart size are unlikely to have diastolic dysfunction.

The authors conclude that, while it is difficult to clinically diagnose left-sided heart failure, certain findings make such a diagnosis more or less likely.

Badgett RG, et al. Can the clinical examination diagnose left-sided heart failure in adults? JAMA. 1997;277:1712–9.


Copyright © 1998 by the American Academy of Family Physicians.
This content is owned by the AAFP. A person viewing it online may make one printout of the material and may use that printout only for his or her personal, non-commercial reference. This material may not otherwise be downloaded, copied, printed, stored, transmitted or reproduced in any medium, whether now known or later invented, except as authorized in writing by the AAFP. Contact afpserv@aafp.org for copyright questions and/or permission requests.

Want to use this article elsewhere? Get Permissions


Article Tools

  • Print page
  • Share this page
  • AFP CME Quiz

Information From Industry

Navigate this Article