Sharing Maternity Care
Access to maternity care is a public health concern in many rural areas. Sharing care among physicians and other health care providers is one solution.
Fam Pract Manag. 2003 Mar;10(3):37-40.
Early and regular prenatal care has been shown to improve perinatal outcomes.1,2 However, women living in rural areas and smaller communities often have difficulty accessing maternity care because they reside in places that generally can’t support an obstetrician or a hospital with a labor and delivery suite. Instead they must travel to larger regional medical centers and, as a result, often delay seeking prenatal care or are seen less frequently during their pregnancies.
One answer to improving access for these women is the “shared care” maternity care management model. This model divides perinatal and postpartum care among two or more health care professionals.
Although there are many ways to share care, one of the most common arrangements is for a family physician in the local community to provide prenatal care and another health care professional (usually an obstetrician/gynecologist) to see the mother periodically during her pregnancy (usually early in the second trimester and for two to three visits close to term) and deliver the child. With this model, the patient continues her relationship with her local physician while establishing a relationship with the obstetrician prior to delivery. Shared care not only improves access to prenatal care, it enhances compliance and encourages continuity of care.1
By sharing prenatal responsibilities, family physicians can care for their pregnant patients without the lifestyle hassles and malpractice risks associated with delivery.
Shared care facilitates early and regular prenatal care for pregnant women in rural areas who may otherwise have difficulty accessing care.
Other benefits include improved continuity of care, increased patient satisfaction and more favorable perinatal outcomes.
Improved care, satisfied patients
A shared-care protocol developed by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) appears on page 39. Dr. Boyle’s practice, Carilion Family Practice, has adapted and used this protocol in shared-care arrangements with several obstetric and gynecologic offices for the past few years. Once a pregnancy is confirmed, each patient is given the option of being referred to the physician of her choice or participating in shared care. Most choose shared care, preferring to have consistent prenatal, postpartum and newborn care. Women meet their delivering doctors for the first time during an antepartum office visit at 18 to 22 weeks gestation. The practice has found that timing the ultrasound to occur as part of this initial visit strengthens the rapport between the patient and physician. Another visit is scheduled during the third trimester or if the pregnancy exceeds 40 weeks gestation.
To facilitate the exchange of patient information between offices, locations within the Carilion Health System use an electronic version of the prenatal chart documentation forms from the AAFP Management of Maternity Care program (www.aafp.org/momcare.xml). Another location is part of a separate hospital system and uses a paper-based version of the prenatal care forms that appear in Guidelines for Perinatal Care, jointly published by the AAP and ACOG and available through their bookstores at www.aap.org and www.acog.org.
Since August 1999, 16 patients in Dr. Boyle’s practice have participated in shared care. Only one patient transferred her care to an obstetrician after initially choosing shared care. One patient miscarried at 24 weeks. All others have successfully delivered or are currently awaiting delivery. One mother is in her second shared-care pregnancy. Others have referred friends to the practice for prenatal care or have said they will use shared care for subsequent pregnancies. Overall, the women have expressed a high degree of satisfaction with shared care and with having their local physician provide as much care as possible.
Malpractice insurance carriers categorize the majority of family physicians who do not practice obstetrics as Class 1 and those who do as up to a Class 4 (obstetricians are usually a Class 8). Premiums increase with each class. These are perhaps the only generalizations that can be made, given the upheaval in the malpractice liability market at this time. When Ginger Boyle, MD, began practicing shared care several years ago, companies were willing to review each physician individually, but they differed as to whether to let these physicians remain a Class 1 or increase their risk to Class 2, 3 or 4. Several insurance companies expressed concern about the risk of intrapartum or neonatal complications. When speaking with malpractice insurance carriers, Dr. Boyle recommends that family physicians define their role in the patient’s care, emphasize that they are providing prenatal care and are not actually performing deliveries, describe their collaboration with the delivering physician and review studies reporting improved patient outcomes and lower incidence of malpractice lawsuits for physicians providing shared care. By doing this, Dr. Boyle remained a Class 1 liability risk.
In a different shared-care arrangement, a rural regional referral hospital in Morehead, Ky., used nurse midwives and family physicians as the primary medical care providers and obstetricians for back-up support. Patients received prenatal care at one of the clinics and were then referred to the medical center for delivery. Nurse midwives cared for most low-risk patients; family physicians assumed responsibility for complicated pregnancies or instrument-assisted deliveries; and obstetricians were consulted for surgical deliveries. During the time the program operated, deliveries to women without prenatal care decreased and more women received prenatal care earlier in their pregnancies.2 Shared care also has been shown to reduce non-labor maternity care admissions and length of stay.3
Physicians who’ve participated in shared care say the key is proper communication and exchange of information. Proper communication with patients involves fully explaining shared care, including the role of the delivering physician and the details described in the protocol. Communication with the delivering physician requires coordination of prenatal forms as well as exchange of lab and office visit data (especially after the initial OB work-up and the 15- and 28-week labs). Family physicians interested in developing shared care should start by proposing the arrangement to their patients’ obstetricians or delivering physicians.
Perceptions and reality
Although most women believe that their family physician can provide competent perinatal care, according to the AAFP, only 28 percent of family practices include obstetrics. In fact, the percentage of family physicians in the United States who deliver babies has declined steadily in the last 20 years. Reasons include perceptions about malpractice risk, attitudes of obstetricians and impact on physicians’ lifestyle and income.4
SHARED CARE PROTOCOL
The primary care physician or other health care provider is responsible for the visits below, as well as for appropriate follow-up unless otherwise indicated. Additional visits with the primary care physician may be required in the first trimester and after the ultrasound, depending on the needs of the patient. Office visits with the delivering physician should be scheduled at 18 to 20 weeks, during the third trimester and after 40 weeks if the patient has not yet delivered.
40 weeks +
Source: American Academy of Pediatrics and American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Guidelines for Perinatal Care. 5th edition. Elk Grove Village, Ill: American Academy of Pediatrics; 2002; and Washington, DC: American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists; 2002.
In Dr. Boyle’s case, perception was far from reality. The malpractice risk she assumed was not insurmountable and once she familiarized her insurance carrier with her shared-care arrangement, her claims have been processed without difficulty (see the box on page 40 for a list of commonly used codes). The obstetricians in her region understand the difficulties of her rural population and have been appreciative of the extra referrals.
Several studies also point to the potential advantages of shared care. For example, in a secondary analysis of a Florida study comparing primary care physicians who practiced obstetrics with those who didn’t, responses from physicians who provided prenatal care but did not do deliveries were separated out as the shared-care group. This group and the group of physicians delivering babies had similar responses. Both groups reported increases in income, professional satisfaction, practice diversity, numbers of complete families in the practice and reduced malpractice risk when compared with the group that did not provide obstetric care.5
In another study, physicians cited the following reasons for including obstetrics in their practices: enjoyment (92 percent), desire to care for younger patients (78 percent), adequate training in residency (77 percent), able to obtain privileges (67 percent), supportive practice (63 percent), acceptable lifestyle (51 percent), community obstetricians supportive (42 percent), affordable malpractice insurance (31 percent), adequate reimbursement (31 percent) and minimal fear of lawsuit (17 percent). It is reasonable then to expect that physicians who provide prenatal care in a shared-care program would enjoy similar benefits and satisfaction.4
Collaboration is key
Improving perinatal outcomes and access to obstetrical care in underserved areas has been given high priority in many states, including Virginia, Florida and Kentucky. Given that the most significant factors for improving outcomes are early and regular prenatal care, and that a lack of easy access to such care is most often the determining factor for delay or noncompliance, shared care provides a viable solution. Making shared care a reality requires partnering with other providers, insurance plans and liability carriers. This is admittedly not an easy task, but it can be rewarding for family physicians seeking to serve and improve the lives of their patients.
COMMONLY USED CPT CODES FOR MATERNITY CARE
COMMONLY USED CPT CODES FOR MATERNITY CARE
|Service provided||CPT code|
Routine obstetric care including antepartum care, vaginal delivery and postpartum care
Antepartum care (1–3 visits); use appropriate level for each visit
Antepartum care only (4–6 visits); includes the “new OB visit”
Antepartum care only (7 or more visits); includes the “initial OB visit”
Postpartum care only
Vaginal delivery only (with or without episiotomy and/or forceps)
Vaginal delivery; including postpartum care
Cesarean delivery only
Cesarean delivery only; including postpartum care
Source: CPT 2003. Professional ed. Chicago: American Medical Association; 2002.
1. Halloran J, Gunn J, Young D. Shared obstetric care: the general practitioner’s perspective. Aust NZ J Obstet Gynaecol. 1992;32:301–305.
2. Hueston WJ, Murry M. A three-tier model for the delivery of rural obstetrical care using a nurse midwife and family physician copractice. J Rural Health. 1992;8(4):283–290.
3. Chan FY, Pun TC, Tse LY, Lai P, Ma HK. Shared antenatal care between family health services and hospital (consultant) services for low risk women. Asia Oceana J Obstet Gynaecol. 1993;19(3):291–298.
4. Roberts RG, Bobula JA, Wolkomir MS. Why family physicians deliver babies. J Fam Pract. 1998;46(1):34–40.
5. Larimore WL, Sapolsky BS. Maternity care in family medicine: economics and malpractice. J Fam Pract. 1995;40:153–160.
Copyright © 2003 by the American Academy of Family Physicians.
This content is owned by the AAFP. A person viewing it online may make one printout of the material and may use that printout only for his or her personal, non-commercial reference. This material may not otherwise be downloaded, copied, printed, stored, transmitted or reproduced in any medium, whether now known or later invented, except as authorized in writing by the AAFP. Contact firstname.lastname@example.org for copyright questions and/or permission requests.
Want to use this article elsewhere? Get Permissions