Given that rural communities across the country are facing a shortage of primary care physicians, research that looks at how to get physicians into rural practice and keep them there is important.
That's why a recent article detailing how female family physicians in small towns and rural communities across the country seemingly "do it all" by managing patient care and their home/family life is timely.
The qualitative study, "Rural Women Family Physicians: Strategies for Successful Work-Life Balance,"(www.annfammed.org) appears in the May/June issue of Annals of Family Medicine.
In their introduction, the authors noted that residents of rural America often travel long distances to see a primary care physician, and statistics show that these communities often face a "disproportionate shortage of women and minority physicians."
- New research published in the May/June issue of Annals of Family Medicine looks at strategies female rural physicians employ to ensure success in practice.
- The study authors identified three key areas discussed by physicians they interviewed: supportive relationships, flexible work hours, and clear boundaries between work and personal life.
- Corresponding author Julie Phillips, M.D., said practices and communities that recruit female physicians should consider policies related to maternity leave, readily available child care and overall physician support.
Researchers highlighted the strengths that female physicians bring to the rural health care table -- including an ability to get female patients to complete screening tests. Female physicians are also more likely than their male peers to deliver babies, said the authors, an important practice characteristic since many rural communities rely on family physicians to provide obstetrical services.
"Promoting the success of women family physicians in rural communities is therefore important for community health," stated the authors.
Corresponding author Julie Phillips, M.D., M.P.H., is an associate professor of family medicine at Michigan State University (MSU) College of Human Medicine in Flint and a faculty member at the Sparrow MSU Family Medicine Residency in Lansing.
Phillips told AAFP News that she's not a rural physician, but her overall interest in workforce issues prompted her to investigate this topic. When the research team conducted a literature search on women in rural practice, they found an uptick in the number of women committing to rural practice, but nothing about strategies they used to make their work possible, said Phillips.
For the study, 25 women -- all family physicians practicing in rural communities and representing 13 states, from Vermont to California -- described through an interview process strategies they used to achieve a successful work-life balance.
Authors discovered that the women's successful rural medicine careers were facilitated by
- supportive relationships with spouses and partners, parents or other members of the community;
- reduced or flexible work hours; and
- maintenance of clear boundaries between their work and personal lives.
Phillips was most intrigued by the level of support the women needed "to make their work doable and how much they really worked to build that support."
Many of the women's male partners had "primary responsibility for managing the household and caring for children," said the authors. "By taking this caregiver role, they allowed their physician partners to be more available to patients."
Regarding the spouses' work arrangements, many of them were self-employed or worked part time, the authors noted, while some had professional careers but worked remotely with urban colleagues.
Furthermore, "Many participants described the support of their life partners as essential for career success." Researchers said physicians acknowledged the sacrifices their partners made and that without those sacrifices, "their chosen professions would not be possible."
Some families also relied on grandparents for assistance with child care or found flexible caregivers outside the family. One physician told interviewers that if she had a patient in labor and needed her mother to come to the house at 2 a.m., she came. "She knows my call schedule and knows what's going on," said the physician.
From Phillips' perspective, "It was very interesting how there was this whole unseen, unacknowledged network of people that allowed the physicians to be available to their patients. It showed there is another side to being successful -- that in order to be a successful physician, it helps to have a team behind you."
Supportive Practice Partners, Flexible Work Hours
According to the study, many physicians interviewed chose rural practice to maintain the broad scope of practice that family medicine allows, including obstetrics, inpatient care, home visits, emergency care and outpatient office hours.
But with that combination of patient services comes great unpredictability in the number of hours worked each week. In fact, when asked about weekly work hours, one physician responded, "Between 40 and 80."
Phillips noted that women reported much support from their practices in the form of flexible work schedules including, in some cases, part-time hours. "And having practice partners who were willing to help out when family obligations arose was important," she added.
One physician said that resisting the urge to move from part-time to full-time employment just to earn more money had been a key decision for her. "If I didn't have those days in between to recharge … or do the laundry, for heaven's sake, I don't know how I would have raised kids," she told her interviewer.
Many physicians said that limiting work hours and protecting personal time "was essential for their well-being" and allowed adequate time for vacation, recreation and parenting.
"Once a year, I take a vacation out of the country, and I don't work Sundays," said one physician.
Physicians also reported reframing "patient expectations" about physicians' days off or approaching them with medical questions in a public place. One physician described her method of redirecting: "I'll give them (patients) a bit of advice but then say, 'Call Tuesday morning and bring them in.'"
But even though physicians took steps to protect their personal time, Phillips said they also exhibited "a really strong sense of devotion to their patients and commitment to their communities."
It was clear that for the most part, physicians also loved their jobs, said Phillips. "So even though the work is difficult and demanding, they also viewed it as being incredibly important and valuable and rewarding work."
Researchers noted that although the study showed women were able to build successful careers in small communities, "the obstacles to rural practice should not be minimized."
Women with young children and those new to practice faced significant challenges, said the authors, and they suggested that practices and communities recruiting physicians consider the needs of families as part of those efforts.
"One message that comes out of the study is that for women to be successful in rural practice, they really do need a lot of support," said Phillips. For instance, when communities are trying to recruit women to rural medicine, they need to consider policies related to maternity leave, readily available child care -- even in the middle of the night -- and overall physician support.
"Those are ways that a community can make a relatively small investment and make a really big impact," she said.
Phillips added that medical educators can help increase the number of female physicians recruited to practice in America's smaller communities by exposing medical students to rural practice. "Students have to see role models -- they have to see that it's feasible or it won't be something they'll really consider," she said.
Related AAFP News Coverage
- 10/04/2017 — GME System Not Meeting Nation's Physician Workforce Needs
- 10/02/2017 — Relatives' Health Piqued Student's Interest in Prevention
- 10/02/2017 — Medical Student Has Immersed Herself in Her Community
- 10/02/2017 — Ohio Medical Student Eager to Practice Rural Family Medicine
- 10/02/2017 — Medical Student Finds Family Medicine Mentors at Stanford
- 10/02/2017 — Relationships, Patient Empowerment Draw Student to Family Medicine
- 09/14/2017 — Delegates Urge AAFP to Address Barrier to Workforce Diversity
- 09/06/2017 — Congress Must Extend DACA Protections
- 07/12/2017 — Study Examines Why Primary Care Physicians Leave Rural Areas
- 07/01/2017 — AAFP Tool Can Connect GME Programs, Save Family Medicine Slots
- 06/12/2017 — CBO Projects Rising Demand for Primary Care Physicians
- 04/24/2017 — Online Applications Open for Additional State Medical Licenses
- 01/25/2017 — Holy Toledo! As Bad Ideas Go, Closing Residency Is a Whopper
- 01/09/2017 — No, I'm Not 'Settling' for Family Medicine
- 01/03/2017 — Direct Primary Care Is a Sensible Workforce Solution
- 11/22/2016 — Doing My Part to Help Physician Workforce Reflect Diverse Population
- 11/18/2016 — Researchers Note Mismatch Between GME, U.S. Population Needs
- 11/08/2016 — Girl Power: Moving Toward Balance in Physician Workforce
- 11/08/2016 — Don't Let Implicit Bias Shape Physician Workforce -- or Patient Care
- 10/31/2016 — Delta Incidents, Film Underscore Need for More Black Female Doctors
- 10/21/2016 — U.S. Medical Schools Still Underproducing Family Physicians
- 10/18/2016 — Study Bolsters Case for Continued Medicaid Funding of GME
- 08/31/2016 — New, Expanding Family Medicine Residencies Aim to Boost Access
- 08/17/2016 — Students Rank Family Medicine No. 1 in Specialty Choice Survey
- 07/27/2016 — $149 Million in HRSA Grants Highlight Primary Care Workforce Needs
- 07/20/2016 — Patient Panel Size Uncertainty Complicates Workforce Projections
- 07/13/2016 — Primary Care Retirement Age Stays Steady Despite Economy, Policies
- 07/06/2016 — High Court Affirms Value of Diversity in Meeting Educational Mission
- 06/28/2016 — Give Back: Making a Plea for Family Medicine Preceptors
- 06/07/2016 — Female Physicians Discuss Strategies for Success in Rural Practice
- 05/13/2016 — Delegates Address Patient Satisfaction as Quality Metric, Other Issues
- 04/25/2016 — AAFP Urges More Federal Funding for Key Primary Care Programs
- 03/31/2016 — Women in Leadership Build Support for Other Female Physicians
- 03/23/2016 — Community Health Centers Play Major Role in Protecting Safety Net
- 03/18/2016 — 2016 Match Sets Record for Family Medicine Choice
- 03/15/2016 — Fake Teen Doc Reflects Need for Real Minority Physicians
- 01/06/2016 — GME Funding, Pipeline Issues Top AAFP's Education Agenda
- 12/16/2015 — Three-year Med School Track Boosts Family Medicine in Texas
- 12/02/2015 — Teaching Health Center Residencies Help Underserved Areas
- 11/24/2015 — Moving On: Finding the Right Job Worth the Effort
- 11/20/2015 — AAFP Joins Brief Supporting Diversity in Med School Admissions
- 11/03/2015 — Michigan Program Recruits Family Medicine Residents Who'll Stick Around
- 10/21/2015 — AAFP Takes Historic Look Back in 2015 Match Analysis
- 10/12/2015 — House Members Launch Primary Care Caucus
- 09/16/2015 — AAFP Calls on Congress to Spare Key Programs From Arbitrary Cuts
- 09/01/2015 — Physician Re-entry Program Aims to Ease Physician Shortage
- 09/01/2015 — Key to Boosting Access Is Expanding the Pipeline
- 08/26/2015 — Former 'Orphan' School Embraces Family Medicine to Drive Progress
- 08/17/2015 — America's Most Wanted: Family Physicians Again Top Search Firm's Wish List
- 08/12/2015 — Despite Challenges, 84 Percent of Residents Happy With Career Choice
- 05/13/2015 — Family Physician Salaries Up but Still Trail Those of Subspecialists
- 03/20/2015 — AAFP Celebrates New Recruits to Family Medicine, Acknowledges Work Ahead
- 03/03/2015 — Significant Primary Care, Overall Physician Shortage Predicted by 2025
- 02/27/2015 — Primary Care, Family Medicine Shine in 2015 Osteopathic Match
- 09/17/2014 — AAFP Proposal Presses for GME System Reform to Meet Nation's Primary Care Needs
- 09/10/2014 — Are U.S. Medical Schools Overlooking Community College Grads?
- 08/06/2014 — Veterans to Get Expanded Access to Primary Care Physicians
- 07/30/2014 — IOM Report Calls for Restructuring of Nation's GME System
- 07/06/2014 — Growing Shortage of Clinical Training Sites Challenges Medical Schools
- 07/02/2014 — CMS Proposed Rule Could Cut Supply of Rural Physicians
- 04/28/2014 — High Salaries Not Key to Satisfaction Among Physicians, Survey Finds
- 07/09/2013 — Demand for Family Physicians Fuels Salary, Compensation Increases, Study Finds
- 06/20/2013 — Geographic Distribution of Primary Care Physicians Affects Health Care, Says Policy Brief
- 11/14/2012 — 52,000 More Primary Care Physicians Needed by 2025
- 07/17/2012 — Family Physician Salaries Rising, Says Survey