American Academy of Family Physicians

Printer-friendly version

Share this on AAFP Connection

Share this page

New Bill Provides Safeguard Against Genetic Discrimination

By James Arvantes

Legislation barring discrimination based on genetic testing may pave the way for greater use of genetic tests to detect various genetically mediated illnesses -- often before they even manifest themselves. With such early detection, development of disease can sometimes be avoided.
Graphic illustration showing DNA helix, chromosomes, etc.
The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act of 2008, H.R. 493, (at the THOMAS Web site, type "H.R. 493" in the search box after selecting "Bill Number") passed the Senate by a 95-0 margin last week, and the House adopted the measure May 1 on a 414-1 vote. The bill prohibits employers from making hiring, assignment or promotion decisions based on genetic data.

The legislation also prohibits insurers from making coverage decisions or establishing premiums based on genetic test results, and it bars insurers from requesting or purchasing a beneficiary's genetic test data.

President Bush has indicated he will sign the legislation, thus making it possible for patients to take advantage of genetic testing without fear of discrimination or reprisals, said Kurt Bardella, press secretary for Sen. Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, sponsor of the Senate legislation.

"Much like our race, our age, our gender, we have no control over what genes we are given at birth," said Bardella, who describes the legislation as a "significant step forward."

"We offer safeguards against other kinds of discrimination, we need to do the same thing for genetic discrimination," he said.

During the past several years, medical science has made tremendous advances in the field of genetic testing, developing 1,500 genetic tests to detect a variety of illnesses at an early stage when disease progression can be halted or even prevented in some cases; yet, many people refuse to take the tests because of "justifiable" fears about discrimination, said Bardella.

"You have to ask yourself, 'What good are genetic breakthroughs if the benefits are not realized by the people who could benefit from them?'" said Bardella. "If genetic tests are left on the shelf, it is as if the progress we have made did not happen."

House and Senate members have been trying to pass a genetic nondiscrimination bill for the past 13 years. In 2003 and 2005, the Senate passed bills by unanimous margins, but the House failed to vote on the legislation. In 2007, the House passed a genetic nondiscrimination bill, but the legislation was blocked in the Senate.

The current Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act has enjoyed overwhelming support in both the House and Senate. In addition, disparate stakeholders, such as local Chambers of Commerce and the insurance industry, have supported the bill, said Sharon Terry. Terry is president and CEO of the Genetic Alliance, a network of health providers and industry groups dedicated to transforming health through genetics.

Ten years ago, only a handful of genetic tests existed for rare diseases, but now, the tests are used to detect more common illnesses, creating a "very different scenario," Terry said. With enactment of H.R. 493, the "general public is going to be interested and care a lot about the fact they can finally obtain genetic information without fearing discrimination."

Share this on AAFP Connection

Government & Medicine

PCMH Is Answer to Medicare Payment Problems

Physician Groups Unite to Call for SGR Repeal

Threatened Medicare Payment Cuts Cause Chaos for FPs

AAFP, Medical Organizations Push for SGR Repeal

Focus of Conference Call is Shared Savings, Advance Payment

AAFP Renews Push for SGR Fix

FPs Can Expect Slight Changes in Medicare Pay for 2012

HHS Approach to Essential Health Benefits Falls Flat

CMS Delays Implementation of 'Sunshine Act'

Congress Works Out Temporary Solution to SGR Cut

Community-based Residencies Would Benefit From House Bill

GME Funding to Remain Level in 2012

House Rejects Measure to Block Medicare Pay Cut

House Addresses Medicare Payment Cut

AAFP Backs Tavenner as New CMS Administrator

Supercommittee Fails to Address SGR

Overcoming Scarce Resources to Enact Health Care Reform

Medicare Payment: Value Is as Important as Volume

AAFP President-elect Makes Return Visit to Capitol Hill

Insurance Exchanges, CO-OPs Might Provide Opportunity for FPs

AAFP Members Speak Out on Title VII Funding

Campaign Addresses Need for Medicare Payment Reform

AAFP Continues to Press Congress for Payment Solution

AAFP Leaders Take On Washington

Campaign Focuses on GME Outreach

'Family Medicine Matters,' AAFP Members Tell Congress

AAFP Outlines Suggested Changes for CO-OP Program

Groups Call on Supercommittee to Address Medical Liability Reform

Grassroots Efforts to Repeal SGR Continue

Bill Linking Mandatory Education to Prescribing Not Needed

Blended Payment Model Gives Boost to Primary Care Services

AAFP Joins AMA, Other Groups in Calling for SGR Repeal

Eliminating SGR May Come With High Price

Tobacco Oversight Must Include Cigars, Say AAFP, Other Groups

AAFP Rallies Congress of Delegates on Medicare Payment

AMA Task Force Focuses on Fixing the SGR

2012 Physician Fee Schedule Needs Work, Says AAFP

New Task Force Takes Steps to Better Value Primary Care

Deficit-reduction Plan Must Eliminate SGR, Says AAFP

Physicians File Lawsuit Over RUC, CMS Relationship

Policy Brief Explains HHS Insurance Exchange Plans

Deficit-reduction Plan Falls Short, Says AAFP President

YouTube Video Designed to Encourage SGR Repeal