AMA, AAFP Seek Physician Exemption From Identity Theft Prevention Program Rules
By News Staff
10/17/2008
The FTC, which wants all such identity theft programs in place by Nov. 1 of this year, would require physicians to establish "reasonable policies and procedures for detecting, preventing and mitigating identity theft," according to the final rules.
"Given that (the) final rules go into effect Nov. 1, 2008, we … request that the FTC withhold any plans to apply the red flag rules to physicians until this matter is resolved," says the AMA in a letter (3-page PDF; About PDFs) that was signed by the AAFP and 25 other medical organizations.
In the letter, the AMA, the AAFP and the other organizations voice strong disagreement with the FTC's interpretation that physicians are creditors and, thus, are subject to the red flag rules. The organizations call on the FTC to "immediately provide a cogent legal analysis and judicial precedence which support the views expressed by some staff attorneys that the final rules are applicable to physicians."
The FTC defines a creditor as any person who regularly extends, renews or continues credit or any person who regularly arranges for the extension, renewal or continuation of credit. The FTC definition also includes any assignee of an original creditor who participates in the decision to extend, renew or continue credit.
"We do not believe that most practicing physicians are 'creditors' under the statutory and regulatory scheme," states the letter. Most physicians do not regularly extend, renew or continue credit, it points out.
The final rule's definition of a creditor specifically mentions lenders, such as banks, finance companies, automobile dealers, mortgage brokers, utility companies and telecommunications companies, the letter says. But it does not include physicians, other health care providers or other types of professionals, such as lawyers or accountants, among the trades or businesses identified as creditors.
The letter acknowledges that some staff attorneys in the Privacy and Identity Protection Section of the FTC have taken the position that physicians are creditors if they bill patients after appointments instead of billing them at the time of their appointments.
"We also question if it is a correct interpretation of the final rule to advise that physicians are creditors if they bill patients after their services are rendered," states the letter. "That would lead to the result that anyone issuing a bill or invoice for services rendered would, by definition, be a creditor, which we do not believe is the intent of the statutory and regulatory scheme."
Furthermore, the letter points out, "if a physician's billing to a patient is due when invoiced, the physician should not thereafter become a creditor for purposes of the final rule simply because the physician agrees, after the fact, to let the patient pay in installments as opposed to turning the matter over to a collection agency or suing the patient."
"Likewise, physicians should not be considered creditors simply because they accept insurance and hold the patient responsible for the amount(s) unpaid by insurance," the letter says. The amount owed by the patient "is not fixed or certain, and there is no extension of credit while the claim is being processed by the insurance company."
AAFP Applauds House Passage of SGR Bill
AAFP Puts Muscle Behind Support for Bill to Fix SGR Formula
AAFP Continues to Press Congress on Health Care Reform
AAFP Letter to House Speaker Expresses Support for Reform Legislation
MedPAC Members Call RBRVS System Subjective, 'Deeply Flawed'
AAFP Leaders Make Case for Family Medicine in Capitol Hill Visits
Legislation Providing Permanent SGR Fix Dies in Senate
Legislation Could Fix SGR Formula
AAFP Supports Rural Physician Legislation
AAFP Leaders, Obama Discuss Health Care Reform in White House Meeting
AAFP President Praises Senate Bill, But Has Some Concerns
Physician Groups Call On Congress to Replace SGR
Obama Rallies Health Care Reform Support
Monday Last Opportunity to Comment on Fee Schedule
Primary Care Key Component of Health Care Reform
AAFP Leaders Engage White House Officials on Reform
Roundtable on Reform Spotlights Primary Care
AAFP Comments on Physician Fee Schedule
Stimulus Funds Help Health Centers
Medicaid EHR Bonus Provides Stimulus
Final Approval Lacking for Medical Home Project
AAFP Board Chair Makes Case for Health Care Reform on Capitol Hill
FP Praises Health IT Bill in Congressional Testimony
Obama Pushes for Health Care Reform in Prime Time News Conference
PCPCC: Feds Call Primary Care 'Fundamental' to Reform
AMA Pushes for Joint Contracting to Achieve Level Playing Field With Insurers
(10/1/2008)
AAFP Renews Call to Change Existing Antitrust Laws
(9/10/2008)
Additional Resources
FTC News Release: 'Red Flag' Regulations Require Financial Institutions and Creditors to Have Identity Theft Prevention Programs
FTC Business Alert: New 'Red Flag' Requirements for Financial Institutions and Creditors Will Help Fight Identity Theft








