American Academy of Family Physicians

Printer-friendly version

Share this on AAFP Connection

Share this page

Q&A With Rep. Allyson Schwartz

Congresswoman Sees Pivotal Role for Family Medicine in Future of Health Care

By James Arvantes

Rep. Allyson Schwartz, D-Pa., is a health care policy expert and a leading congressional proponent of primary care and the patient-centered medical home. As a former health care executive and social worker, Schwartz is well aware of the critical role primary care plays in improving health care quality, enhancing access to care and containing costs.

In 2012, the five-term congresswoman, along with Rep. Joseph Heck, D.O., R-Nev., introduced the Medicare Physician Payment Innovation Act which would immediately eliminate the sustainable growth rate (SGR) formula by using savings from reductions in military operations in Iraq and Afghanistan to cover the $300 billion cost of a repeal. In the process, the bill would block a 26.5 percent reduction in the Medicare payment rate scheduled to take effect on Jan. 1.
Glen Stream, MD, talking with Rep. Allyson Schwartz
Rep. Allyson Schwartz, D-Pa., shown here with (then) AAFP President Glen Stream, M.D., M.B.I., says there is an understanding in Congress that family physicians are critically important to making sure patients get the care they need.
The bill also would provide a 2.5 percent increase in payments for primary care physicians during the next four years in an attempt to address the undervaluation of primary care services, preventive care and care coordination services.

Schwartz is the vice ranking member of the House Budget Committee and co-chair of the New Democrat Coalition Health Care Task Force. She also is a former member of the House Ways and Means Committee, and, in the upcoming 113th Congress, she will serve on that committee again.

AAFP News Now recently spoke with Schwartz about health care issues and the role of primary care and the PCMH in the nation's health care system.

Q. Why did you want to introduce the Medicare Physician Payment Innovation Act?

A. It is important for us to not only repeal the SGR policy that has failed to contain the growth in costs or improve quality, but to actually replace it with a policy that moves health care providers and all Medicare beneficiaries in the direction of improved quality (and) improved outcomes while containing the rate of growth in costs. This means providing the right kind of care in a timely fashion.

Q. What role did the AAFP play in helping draft this legislation?

A.
I have appreciated all of the input and ideas from the AAFP, as well as their expertise. It is very important for me to be informed in terms of what is happening in delivery system reform -- where the AAFP has taken some leadership -- and also to be sure that we are providing incentives and greater availability for primary care as a way to improve quality and improve coordination of care for our seniors, particularly those with chronic diseases.

Q. Why did you feel it was important to include a 2 percent increase for primary care in the bill?

A. Access to primary care for seniors in our country, particularly those with serious chronic diseases, is extremely important in ensuring that seniors have access to the care they need and that they are getting the kind of health care to maintain their health. Primary care physicians are extremely important in that process.

Q. What are your views on the PCMH?

A. The patient-centered medical home has already shown that it can reduce costs and improve quality of care. The PCMH gives the primary care physician the ability to be (better) reimbursed for coordinating care and to reach out to patients with other health care personnel to make sure patients are getting the right kind of care when they need it.

Congresswoman Sees SGR Repeal on the Horizon

Rep. Allyson Schwartz, D-Pa., is convinced that Congress finally will succeed in repealing the sustainable growth rate (SGR) formula in 2013 as part of a larger budget deal between Congress and the White House.

"I see full SGR repeal as paid for and a replacement in how we pay physicians done in the next few months as part of a broader fiscal package," said Schwartz in a recent interview with AAFP News Now.

Schwartz cautioned, however, that this is contingent on an actual budget deal.

"If we actually avoid the fiscal cliff and set ourselves on a path to deficit reduction and fiscally sustainable budget scenarios and sustainable Medicare, SGR repeal and a new system of paying doctors should be a part of that," said Schwartz.

Like other lawmakers, Schwartz cited the cost of a SGR repeal as the reason why the formula still is in place. Although the SGR has not been repealed, it has never really been implemented.

"The SGR stays in the budget calculations as an anticipated savings," said Schwartz. "It is real money, and in budget terms, we have to find a way to pay for those anticipated savings, to make up for those anticipated savings. In tough fiscal times, that is not easy to do."

In the short term, Congress is focused on preventing a 26.5 percent cut in Medicare physician payment scheduled to take effect on Jan. 1 as a result of the SGR, according to Schwartz. But it is important, she added, to lift the consistent threat to physician payment caused by the SGR. "In the longer term," Schwartz said, "we have to set ourselves on a path to repeal (the SGR) and pay for (the repeal)."
Q. Do you feel that the PCMH represents the future of primary care?

A. I think it is a very important part of primary care and has been embraced by many primary care practitioners. It already has been shown to improve health outcomes for patients, improve satisfaction among physicians and contain the rate of growth in health care costs in the right way.

Q. Does the PCMH represent the future of health care in this country?

A. It is a part of it. There is no question that for many of us, we are looking for more coordinated care, better coordinated care between the primary care practitioner and the patient, between primary care physicians and the (sub)specialists, and between institutions of care.

Q. What would you say is the role of family physicians in the nation's health care system?

A. Family physicians, as primary care physicians, are critical to making sure that patients get the care they need and are referred to (sub)specialists when they need to be referred to (sub)specialists. They also follow up with the patient's health care needs. Family physicians are very much the linchpin to some of the health care reform efforts we are facing. They are really very important to ensuring continuity of care.

Q. How do you think family physicians are perceived in Congress?

A.
They are thought of as the physicians who are there for patients. There is a greater understanding in Congress of family physicians being critically important to making sure our patients get the care that they need and reducing costs in the right way.

Q. Is there an understanding among lawmakers that many family physicians also are small business owners?

A. I think there is less of an understanding of that. I think there is an understanding that family practice physicians are not paid as highly as (sub)specialists. There is a keen understanding of that. There probably is a smaller group of us who understand the distinctions between the different specialties. I believe family practice physicians are valued by members of Congress.

Q. You have talked about the critical role primary care and family physicians play in the health care system. Why do you think the role of primary care and family physicians is not better recognized and rewarded among public and private payers?

A. The system of health care reimbursement certainly has rewarded procedures and interventions much more so than office visits and chronic disease management and many of the things that primary care physicians do -- things that are harder to quantify. There is an increased understanding of how important it is to reimburse for the time that it takes to know patients and understand their medical issues so (physicians) can make the right kind of diagnosis and develop appropriate strategies for their care.

Q. Do your colleagues in the House have the same knowledge of primary care that you have?

A. To some extent, yes. But it is always important to have that dialogue with members of Congress. I always encourage people, and certainly physicians, to talk with their members of Congress about the critical role primary care and family physicians, in particular, play in providing quality of care for our seniors and all Americans.

Q. Why do you have such an interest in health care?

A. I have worked in health care. I have run a health center. I have done health care policy for a number of years here in Congress and previously in the (Pennsylvania) state senate. It is something I am knowledgeable about and look forward to continuing to work on to make sure all Americans have access to affordable, meaningful health coverage. That includes a health system that provides the right kind of care in a cost-efficient manner and improves the outcomes of health status for all Americans.

Share this on AAFP Connection

Search AAFP News Now

 

Government & Medicine

FMCC Highlights Growing Influence of Primary Care

AAFP Seeking Information on Parity Program

Bipartisan Study Looks for How to Save Health Care

Academy Pushes for Payment Reform

AAFP Announces Support for Truth in Advertising Measure

U.S. Needs to Invest in Primary Care, Says AAFP Member

AAFP Answers Questions on Health IT Expansion

Repeal OTC Provision, Says AAFP

AAFP Responds to Proposal on SGR, Medicare Payment Fix

President's Budget Proposes Cuts in GME

AAFP Pushes for Tavenner Confirmation as CMS Head

ONC Launches Online Health IT Discussion Forum

State Medicaid Programs Drive PCMH Initiatives Forward

Sequestration Cuts Go Into Effect

Report Calls for Changes in Physician Payment Models

AAFP Outlines Funding Needed for FP Training Programs

Team-based Care Is in Patients' Best Interest, Says AAFP Director

Community-based Primary Care Training Is Focus of Legislation

Speakers Give Political Insight Into Health Care Reform

What Sequestration Cuts Mean for Family Physicians

AAFP Notes Concerns About Global Surgical Package Codes

House Republicans Draft Proposal to Repeal SGR

Sequestration Cuts to Take Effect April 1

AAFP Takes Payment Reform Message to Capitol Hill

CMS Releases Final Sunshine Act Rule

Sequestration Cuts Prompt Grass-roots Outreach

AAFP Responds to State of Union Address

Members Offer Opinions on Medical School Debt

States Need to Speedily Implement Parity Provision

Legislation Would Eliminate Broken Medicare Payment Formula

Senate Committee Recognizes Role of Primary Care Physicians

Nation Must Support Primary Care Infrastructure, Says AAFP

Family Medicine Can Play Role in Stemming Violence

Further Budget Cuts Likely in March

Analysts Tally 2011 U.S. Health Care Spending Growth

Despite Delays, FPs Can Expect Full Payment on Parity Provision

Budget Deal Averts Medicare Payment Cuts

AAFP Supports Key Provisions of Health Care Reform

Congresswoman Sees Primary Care as Future of Health Care

FPs Need to Think About Medicare Options

VA Proposal Would Incorporate More Non-VA Physicians

Physician Groups Present United Front on SGR Cuts

AAFP Sets Legislative Priorities for Family Medicine

Groups Speak Out Against Elimination of Payment Parity

AAFP Unites Members to Speak Out to Congress on Cuts

FP Community Takes Steps to Protect GME Funding

AAFP Outlines Strategies for Curtailing Prescription Drug Abuse

Proposed Rules Cover ACA Provisions

AAFP Joins Other Groups Seeking to Overturn Florida Law

AAFP Continues to Press Congress for Payment Solution

'Family Medicine Matters,' AAFP Members Tell Congress

Groups Call on Supercommittee to Address Medical Liability Reform

Grassroots Efforts to Repeal SGR Continue

AAFP Joins AMA, Other Groups in Calling for SGR Repeal

Eliminating SGR May Come With High Price

Tobacco Oversight Must Include Cigars, Say AAFP, Other Groups

AAFP Rallies Congress of Delegates on Medicare Payment

AMA Task Force Focuses on Fixing the SGR

2012 Physician Fee Schedule Needs Work, Says AAFP

New Task Force Takes Steps to Better Value Primary Care

Deficit-reduction Plan Must Eliminate SGR, Says AAFP

Policy Brief Explains HHS Insurance Exchange Plans

Deficit-reduction Plan Falls Short, Says AAFP President

YouTube Video Designed to Encourage SGR Repeal