This was successfully posted to your pofile.
This box will close automatically in a few seconds. Close this window
We don't have an e-mail address on file for you. To use AAFP Connection, you must have an e-mail address in our records. Click Here
Study: 'Web 2.0' Technologies Pose Challenges in Teaching Medical Professionalism
Facebook, Twitter Postings Can Hurt Patients, Students' Careers, Say Educators
By Barbara Bein
Even so, it's imperative to raise students' consciousness that such postings can hurt their careers and their relationships with future patients, said medical educators interviewed by AAFP News Now. According to the study, medical schools would do well to include discussions about digital media in their curriculum on professionalism.
Extent of the Problem
The study results are based on a survey in March and April 2009 by researchers at George Washington University, or GWU, Washington, D.C., and Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore. Researchers surveyed the deans of student affairs or their proxies in each of the (then) 130 accredited allopathic U.S. medical schools represented by the Association of American Medical Colleges, or AAMC. The survey asked about incidents of unprofessional student-posted online content, level of concern about the problem, and the existence of plans for developing institutional policies covering student-posted online content.
Of the 78 medical schools that responded to the survey, 60 percent reported such incidents, including violations of patient confidentiality, profanity, discriminatory language, depiction of intoxication or illicit substance use, sexually suggestive material and negative communications about the medical profession or patients.
The most frequent incidents reported in the study involved profanity, intoxication and sexually suggestive material. Postings that violated patient confidentiality -- mostly blogs that described clinical experiences with details that could identify patients -- were not the most common incidents, but they were certainly cause for concern, according to the study's lead author, Katherine Chretien, M.D., an assistant professor of medicine at the GWU School of Medicine and Health Sciences.
"Students need to be aware that their professionalism and character may be judged on what they put out there on the Internet," Chretien told AAFP News Now.
"We've heard so many stories of people getting fired from their jobs for what they write or post online, and the same can hold true for medical students -- and residents and staff physicians. Protecting patient privacy is paramount and everyone who deals with protected health information needs to be vigilant about this," she added.
Indeed, said George Harris, M.D., M.S., of Lee's Summit, Mo., assistant dean for year 1 and 2 medicine at the University of Missouri-Kansas City School of Medicine, or UMKC, and professor of medicine in the UMKC Department of Community and Family Medicine. Some students "have crossed over from an innocent mode of socialization to unprofessional behavior," he noted.
"These unprofessional activities have the potential to affect the students' applications to a residency program, their first job interviews as a physician and, eventually, their caring for patients," he told AAFP News Now. The consequences of posting such sensitive information could imperil one's own reputation or that of another student, colleague or faculty member, said Harris.
But beyond the personal consequences, the postings can have the effect of discriminating against patients, perhaps even limiting their access to care, he added.
Focus on Web 2.0 Apps
A much larger group -- 62 percent -- said their schools' current professionalism policies do not cover student-posted online content or they weren't sure whether they did.
Of deans in medical schools without policies covering student-posted online content, 11 percent said they were developing or revising existing policies to address this issue, and 50 percent said they were planning to make such changes. Others did not think revisions or new policies were necessary (20 percent) or they weren't sure (20 percent).
The study concluded, "Many responding schools had incidents of unprofessional student online postings, but they may not have adequate policy in place" to deal with such incidents.
Moreover, discussions on relevant laws, such as the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act and the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, also should be incorporated into the curriculum.
"At the very least, there should be increased awareness, education and conversation about this in medical school," Chretien said. "Whether schools develop Internet-specific policies is up to individual schools. Students' views and perspectives need to be incorporated in whatever path a school chooses to best prepare students entering this profession in our increasingly digital world."
Recommended Curriculum Guidelines for Family Medicine Residents: Medical Ethics
(8-page PDF; About PDFs)