Jul 15, 2012 Issue
 
 

Editorials

Choosing Wisely: Top Interventions to Improve Health and Reduce Harm, While Lowering Costs

 

JAY SIWEK, MD, Georgetown University Medical Center, Washington, DC

Am Fam Physician. 2012 Jul 15;86(2):128-133.

Sometimes, the hardest thing for a physician to do is nothing: not ordering magnetic resonance imaging for a patient with acute, uncomplicated back pain; not prescribing antibiotics for a simple upper respiratory tract infection; not reaching for the prescription pad when patients—exhorted by a television advertisement—ask if some new medicine is “right for them.” And although patients are sometimes a source of excess utilization, physicians, responding to conventional practices, current fads, and the rituals of medicine, often order tests or treatments that don't stand up to clinical scrutiny. How do we do better? How do we know not only what to do, but also what not to do?

For years, we've had the benefit of practice guidelines, although these tend to focus mainly on what to do. A new program, the Choosing Wisely campaign, now prompts physicians and patients to avoid unnecessary testing and treatment, things that not only don't help, but that also may lead to harm.

Initially sponsored by nine medical specialty societies, the campaign consists of specialty-specific top-five lists of common tests and procedures that are often performed unnecessarily, when they are not likely to improve a patient's health. The primary focus of the campaign is to improve health care quality and reduce harm by avoiding unnecessary interventions, with the added benefit of lowering costs. Even seemingly innocuous interventions, such as magnetic resonance imaging or a simple blood test, can be harmful, even fatal, if they lead to additional testing, invasive procedures, and a small but predictable rate of complications.

More information about the Choosing Wisely campaign is available at http://choosingwisely.org. In addition, Consumer Reports Health is helping get the word out to consumers (http://consumerhealthchoices.org/campaigns/choosing-wisely). The campaign's lead paper was recently published as part of the “Less Is More” series in Archives of Internal Medicine, and contains the top-five lists from family medicine, internal medicine, and pediatrics.1  However, given family medicine's broad scope, segregating various items into specialty-specific lists is somewhat artificial. To avoid unnecessarily limiting these lists to just five areas in which quality of care could be improved, I've compiled all the relevant items from the three primary care specialties (see accompanying table).

 Enlarge     Print

Table.

Interventions to Improve Health Care Quality and Reduce Harm: Consolidated Items from Primary Care's Top-Five Lists

InterventionBackground and rationaleSource of recommendation

Don't perform imaging for low back pain within the first six weeks unless red flags are present (FM, IM)

note: Red flags include, but are not limited to, severe or progressive neurologic deficits or when serious underlying conditions such as osteomyelitis are suspected

Imaging of the lumbar spine before six weeks does not improve outcomes, but does increase cost

Low back pain is the fifth most common reason for all physician visits

Agency for Health Care Policy and Research

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

Don't routinely prescribe antibiotics for acute, mild to moderate sinusitis unless symptoms (which must include purulent nasal secretions and maxillary pain or facial or dental tenderness to percussion) last for at least seven days or symptoms worsen after initial clinical improvement (FM)

Most cases of maxillary sinusitis in the ambulatory setting are caused by a viral infection that will resolve on its own

Despite consistent recommendations to the contrary, antibiotics are prescribed in more than 80 percent of outpatient visits for acute sinusitis

Sinusitis accounts for 16 million office visits and $5.8 billion in annual health care costs

Annals of Internal Medicine

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

Don't order annual electrocardiography or any other cardiac screening for asymptomatic, low-risk patients (FM, IM)

Little evidence that detection of coronary artery stenosis improves health outcomes in asymptomatic patients at low risk of coronary heart disease

False-positive test results are likely to lead to harm through unnecessary invasive procedures, overtreatment, and misdiagnosis

Potential harms of routine annual screening exceed the potential benefit

USPSTF

Don't perform Pap tests in patients younger than 21 years or in women after hysterectomy for benign disease (FM)

Most dysplasia in adolescents regresses spontaneously; therefore, screening Pap tests in this age group can lead to unnecessary anxiety, morbidity, and cost

Pap tests have low yield in women after hysterectomy for benign disease, and there is poor evidence for improved outcomes

American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (for age)

USPSTF (for hysterectomy)

Don't use dual energy x-ray absorptiometry to screen for osteoporosis in women younger than 65 years or in men younger than 70 years with no risk factors (FM, IM)

note: Risk factors include, but are not limited to, fractures after 50 years of age, prolonged exposure to corticosteroids, diet deficient in calcium or vitamin D, cigarette smoking, alcoholism, and thin/small build

Not cost-effective in younger, low-risk patients, but cost-effective in older patients

American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists

American College of Preventive Medicine

National Osteoporosis Foundation

USPSTF

Don't obtain blood chemistry panels (e.g., basic metabolic panel) or perform urinalyses for screening in asymptomatic, healthy adults (IM)

Only lipid screening yielded a significant number of positive results among asymptomatic patients

Screen for type 2 diabetes mellitus in asymptomatic adults with hypertension

USPSTF

Use only generic statins when initiating lipid-lowering drug therapy (IM)

All statins are effective in decreasing mortality, heart attacks, and strokes when dose is titrated to effect appropriate LDL cholesterol reduction

Switch to more expensive brand-name statins (atorvastatin [Lipitor] or rosuvastatin [Crestor]) only if generic statins cause clinical reactions or do not achieve LDL cholesterol goals

CURVES and MERCURY trials and meta-analyses

Don't prescribe antibiotics for pharyngitis unless the child tests positive for streptococcal infection (Ped)

Most cases of pharyngitis are viral and will not respond to antibiotics, yet antibiotics are prescribed more than half of the time

Antibiotic use has potential risks to the child, increases bacterial antibiotic resistance, and adds to health care expenses

The absence of fever, cervical lymphadenopathy, and tonsillar exudates, and the presence of cough suggest a viral etiology; screening for streptococcal infection may be unnecessary if these criteria are present

Confirmation of streptococcal infection is necessary before antibiotic use can be justified

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

Essential Evidence Plus

Don't obtain diagnostic images for minor head injuries in children without loss of consciousness or other risk factors (Ped)

Imaging in low-risk patients rarely detects traumatic abnormalities, and of the abnormalities detected, few, if any, require surgery

Higher risk factors include dizziness, external signs of injury, changes in neurologic function, a dangerous mechanism of injury (e.g., bicycle-related injury, a fall from 3 ft or more or five stairs), age younger than two years, Glasgow Coma Scale score of less than 15, and evidence of basilar skull fracture (e.g., “raccoon eyes,” hemotympanum)

Early exposure to radiation poses a significant risk of radiation-attributed cancers—as high as one case in 1,400 infants exposed to cranial computed tomography

AAFP/AAP guidelines

Don't refer children who have otitis media with effusion early in the course of the problem (Ped)

Many cases of otitis media with effusion resolve spontaneously within three months with no adverse consequences

Reasons for early referral include craniofacial or neurologic abnormalities, language delay or learning problems, and suspected structural abnormalities of the eardrum or middle ear

AAFP/AAP guidelines

National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence

Advise that children not use cough and cold medications (Ped)

There is little evidence that over-the-counter cough and cold medications reduce cough or rhinorrhea, or shorten the duration of illness in children; rather, they can cause adverse consequences, including death

Yet, more than 10 percent of children use a cough and cold medication every week

AAP

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

U.S. Food and Drug Administration

Use inhaled corticosteroids to appropriately control asthma in children (Ped)

Use of a controlling medication for persistent asthma reduces asthma exacerbations, emergency department visits, and hospital admissions

Threshold: More than four wheezing episodes or two episodes requiring oral corticosteroids within six months

Inhaled corticosteroids are relatively safe and well tolerated

National Asthma Education and Prevention Program

note: FM = from family medicine's top-five list; IM = from internal medicine's top-five list; Ped = from pediatrics' top-five list.

AAFP = American Academy of Family Physicians; AAP = American Academy of Pediatrics; LDL = low-density lipoprotein; Pap = Papanicolaou; USPSTF = U.S. Preventive Services Task Force.

Adapted with permission from Good Stewardship Working Group. The “top 5” lists in primary care: meeting the responsibility of professionalism. Arch Intern Med. 2011;171(15):1385–1390. http://archinte.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=1105881. Accessed May 10, 2012.

Table.

Interventions to Improve Health Care Quality and Reduce Harm: Consolidated Items from Primary Care's Top-Five Lists

InterventionBackground and rationaleSource of recommendation

Don't perform imaging for low back pain within the first six weeks unless red flags are present (FM, IM)

note: Red flags include, but are not limited to, severe or progressive neurologic deficits or when serious underlying conditions such as osteomyelitis are suspected

Imaging of the lumbar spine before six weeks does not improve outcomes, but does increase cost

Low back pain is the fifth most common reason for all physician visits

Agency for Health Care Policy and Research

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

Don't routinely prescribe antibiotics for acute, mild to moderate sinusitis unless symptoms (which must include purulent nasal secretions and maxillary pain or facial or dental tenderness to percussion) last for at least seven days or symptoms worsen after initial clinical improvement (FM)

Most cases of maxillary sinusitis in the ambulatory setting are caused by a viral infection that will resolve on its own

Despite consistent recommendations to the contrary, antibiotics are prescribed in more than 80 percent of outpatient visits for acute sinusitis

Sinusitis accounts for 16 million office visits and $5.8 billion in annual health care costs

Annals of Internal Medicine

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

Don't order annual electrocardiography or any other cardiac screening for asymptomatic, low-risk patients (FM, IM)

Little evidence that detection of coronary artery stenosis improves health outcomes in asymptomatic patients at low risk of coronary heart disease

False-positive test results are likely to lead to harm through unnecessary invasive procedures, overtreatment, and misdiagnosis

Potential harms of routine annual screening exceed the potential benefit

USPSTF

Don't perform Pap tests in patients younger than 21 years or in women after hysterectomy for benign disease (FM)

Most dysplasia in adolescents regresses spontaneously; therefore, screening Pap tests in this age group can lead to unnecessary anxiety, morbidity, and cost

Pap tests have low yield in women after hysterectomy for benign disease, and there is poor evidence for improved outcomes

American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (for age)

USPSTF (for hysterectomy)

Don't use dual energy x-ray absorptiometry to screen for osteoporosis in women younger than 65 years or in men younger than 70 years with no risk factors (FM, IM)

note: Risk factors include, but are not limited to, fractures after 50 years of age, prolonged exposure to corticosteroids, diet deficient in calcium or vitamin D, cigarette smoking, alcoholism, and thin/small build

Not cost-effective in younger, low-risk patients, but cost-effective in older patients

American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists

American College of Preventive Medicine

National Osteoporosis Foundation

USPSTF

Don't obtain blood chemistry panels (e.g., basic metabolic panel) or perform urinalyses for screening in asymptomatic, healthy adults (IM)

Only lipid screening yielded a significant number of positive results among asymptomatic patients

Screen for type 2 diabetes mellitus in asymptomatic adults with hypertension

USPSTF

Use only generic statins when initiating lipid-lowering drug therapy (IM)

All statins are effective in decreasing mortality, heart attacks, and strokes when dose is titrated to effect appropriate LDL cholesterol reduction

Switch to more expensive brand-name statins (atorvastatin [Lipitor] or rosuvastatin [Crestor]) only if generic statins cause clinical reactions or do not achieve LDL cholesterol goals

CURVES and MERCURY trials and meta-analyses

Don't prescribe antibiotics for pharyngitis unless the child tests positive for streptococcal infection (Ped)

Most cases of pharyngitis are viral and will not respond to antibiotics, yet antibiotics are prescribed more than half of the time

Antibiotic use has potential risks to the child, increases bacterial antibiotic resistance, and adds to health care expenses

The absence of fever, cervical lymphadenopathy, and tonsillar exudates, and the presence of cough suggest a viral etiology; screening for streptococcal infection may be unnecessary if these criteria are present

Confirmation of streptococcal infection is necessary before antibiotic use can be justified

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

Essential Evidence Plus

Don't obtain diagnostic images for minor head injuries in children without loss of consciousness or other risk factors (Ped)

Imaging in low-risk patients rarely detects traumatic abnormalities, and of the abnormalities detected, few, if any, require surgery

Higher risk factors include dizziness, external signs of injury, changes in neurologic function, a dangerous mechanism of injury (e.g., bicycle-related injury, a fall from 3 ft or more or five stairs), age younger than two years, Glasgow Coma Scale score of less than 15, and evidence of basilar skull fracture (e.g., “raccoon eyes,” hemotympanum)

Early exposure to radiation poses a significant risk of radiation-attributed cancers—as high as one case in 1,400 infants exposed to cranial computed tomography

AAFP/AAP guidelines

Don't refer children who have otitis media with effusion early in the course of the problem (Ped)

Many cases of otitis media with effusion resolve spontaneously within three months with no adverse consequences

Reasons for early referral include craniofacial or neurologic abnormalities, language delay or learning problems, and suspected structural abnormalities of the eardrum or middle ear

AAFP/AAP guidelines

National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence

Advise that children not use cough and cold medications (Ped)

There is little evidence that over-the-counter cough and cold medications reduce cough or rhinorrhea, or shorten the duration of illness in children; rather, they can cause adverse consequences, including death

Yet, more than 10 percent of children use a cough and cold medication every week

AAP

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

U.S. Food and Drug Administration

Use inhaled corticosteroids to appropriately control asthma in children (Ped)

Use of a controlling medication for persistent asthma reduces asthma exacerbations, emergency department visits, and hospital admissions

Threshold: More than four wheezing episodes or two episodes requiring oral corticosteroids within six months

Inhaled corticosteroids are relatively safe and well tolerated

National Asthma Education and Prevention Program

note: FM = from family medicine's top-five list; IM = from internal medicine's top-five list; Ped = from pediatrics' top-five list.

AAFP = American Academy of Family Physicians; AAP = American Academy of Pediatrics; LDL = low-density lipoprotein; Pap = Papanicolaou; USPSTF = U.S. Preventive Services Task Force.

Adapted with permission from Good Stewardship Working Group. The “top 5” lists in primary care: meeting the responsibility of professionalism. Arch Intern Med. 2011;171(15):1385–1390. http://archinte.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=1105881. Accessed May 10, 2012.

Other medical specialties have already joined the campaign and will contribute their top-five lists in the coming months. To help our readers, American Family Physician will maintain a running catalog of items relevant to family medicine on our Web site (see “Choosing Wisely: Top Interventions to Improve Health Care Quality and Reduce Harm” at https://www.aafp.org/online/en/home/publications/journals/afp/ebmtoolkit/choosingwisely.html).

editor's note: Dr. Siwek is editor of American Family Physician.

Address correspondence to Jay Siwek, MD, at siwekj@georgetown.edu. Reprints are not available from the author.

Author disclosure: No relevant financial affiliations to disclose.

 

REFERENCE

1. Good Stewardship Working Group. The “top 5” lists in primary care: meeting the responsibility of professionalism. Arch Intern Med. 2011;171(15):1385–1390.

 

 

Copyright © 2012 by the American Academy of Family Physicians.
This content is owned by the AAFP. A person viewing it online may make one printout of the material and may use that printout only for his or her personal, non-commercial reference. This material may not otherwise be downloaded, copied, printed, stored, transmitted or reproduced in any medium, whether now known or later invented, except as authorized in writing by the AAFP. Contact afpserv@aafp.org for copyright questions and/or permission requests.

  • PRINT

Want to use this article elsewhere? Get Permissions


More in AFP


Related Content

More in Pubmed


MOST RECENT ISSUE


Oct 2021

Access the latest issue of American Family Physician

Read the Issue


Email Alerts

Don't miss a single issue. Sign up for the free AFP email table of contents.

Sign Up Now

Navigate this Article