to the editor: The excellent review of recurrent thrombosis and hypercoagulability1 failed to mention the increased risk of thromboembolic events associated with use of unopposed estrogen therapy or estrogen-progestin hormone replacement therapy, or with endogenous estrogen dominance relative to progesterone.
The increased risk of thromboembolic events secondary to estrogen therapy has long been known by experienced physicians. A recent letter1 reports a venous thromboembolic risk 2.0 to 3.6 times higher in estrogen-progestin hormone replacement therapy users than in nonusers.1 A well-referenced review article3 presents strong evidence that higher fibrinogen levels, higher blood viscosity, and less filterable, stiffer red blood cells occur during the follicular phase of the menstrual cycle than during the progesterone-rich secretory phase.
Thus, solid research indicates that (1) estrogen is a potent risk factor in thromboembolic events and (2) progestins (foreign, synthetic progesterone-like compounds) offer little protection against estrogen-induced thromboembolic events, whereas progesterone is protective. It would have been appropriate for Drs. Harris and Abramson to include this knowledge in Table 1 of their article.
in reply: We are grateful to Dr. Lee for the comments regarding the association of estrogenic factors and hypercoagulability. Indeed, estrogens and estrogen analogs, such as tamoxifen (Nolvadex) are associated with deep venous thrombosis and pulmonary emboli.
It was our purpose to review the primary coagulation disorders. However, as long as Dr. Lee raises the subject of estrogenic influences, we would like to reemphasize a point we made: estrogen-associated hypercoagulation may be related to primary coagulation defects. Women with known abnormalities of the protein S and C pathways (including factor V leiden) are at greater risk for thrombosis when estrogens are used.1 Future epidemiologic data might reveal that a number of women in the general population who develop hypercoagulability with the use of estrogen therapy (or with use of tamoxifen) have unrecognized coagulation abnormalities.