Spironolactone (Aldactone) is a potassium-sparing diuretic that was approved many years ago. Until recently, it was used primarily to treat edema resulting from liver cirrhosis, primary hyperaldosteronism and nephrotic syndrome. It has been used in combination with potassium-wasting diuretics to prevent hypokalemia.
Recent research on this older diuretic has focused on its effect in patients with left-sided congestive heart failure (CHF). As an aldosterone-blocking agent, spironolactone is postulated to work synergistically with angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors to provide more thorough blockade of the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone (RAA) system.
The RAA system is the complex mechanism by which the kidneys control the cardiovascular system. The system goes awry in patients with heart failure; in these persons, the decreased renal blood flow is not due to low blood volume but to a heart pump that is not working efficiently. ACE inhibitors block the conversion of vasoconstrictor angiotensin I to the much more potent angiotensin II, also blocking the production of the sodium-retaining hormone aldosterone. This production is only transiently suppressed, thus allowing aldosterone production to “escape” the effects of the ACE inhibitors.1
Spironolactone is a specialized antagonist of aldosterone. It acts as a competitive binding agent at the aldosterone receptor site in the distal convoluted renal tubules, preventing the formation of a protein important in the sodium-potassium exchange in the kidneys. This action causes increased amounts of water and sodium to be excreted while potassium is conserved.
Evidence of Benefit in Heart Failure
Based on earlier work suggesting a benefit of therapy,2 the Randomized Aldactone Evaluation Study (RALES) was undertaken to evaluate the role of spironolactone when used in addition to standard therapy for CHF. Standard therapy in this study did not include beta blockers.3 The investigators prospectively enrolled 1,663 patients with severe (New York Heart Association [NYHA] class IV) CHF (Table 1).4 Most of the enrolled patients were white men averaging 65 years of age. These patients had a left ventricular ejection fraction of 35 percent or less and marked physical limitations related to CHF. Patients were excluded if they had unstable angina or moderate renal failure, and if they were hyperkalemic.
All patients who could tolerate the drug were given an ACE inhibitor and a loop diuretic, and 70 percent were taking digoxin. Only 10 percent were taking beta blockers. Patients were randomly assigned to receive placebo or 25 mg of spironolactone daily in addition to their current regimen. After eight weeks, if the patient showed worsening CHF and had a stable potassium level, the dosage was increased to 50 mg daily. The dosage was decreased to 25 mg every other day if at any time the patient became hyperkalemic.
Even with a 25 percent dropout rate (414 patients) among the two groups, related to adverse effects or lack of response, the results in the remaining patients in the study indicated a 30 percent reduction in death (35 versus 46 percent) over two years. During the study period, one death was avoided for every nine patients receiving spironolactone (number needed to treat [NNT] = 9).
|I||Patients with cardiac disease but without resulting limitations of physical activity. Ordinary physical activity does not cause undue fatigue or dyspnea.|
|II||Patients with cardiac disease resulting in slight limitation of physical activity. They are comfortable at rest. Ordinary physical activity results in fatigue or dyspnea.|
|III||Patients with cardiac disease resulting in marked limitation of physical activity. They are comfortable at rest. Less than ordinary physical activity causes fatigue or dyspnea.|
|IV||Patients with cardiac disease resulting in inability to carry on any physical activity without discomfort. Symptoms of cardiac insufficiency or of the anginal syndrome may be present even at rest. If any physical activity is undertaken, discomfort is increased.|
The number of hospitalizations related to worsening CHF was lowered by 35 percent. NYHA classification improved in the spironolactone group more than in the placebo group. The primary adverse effect causing discontinuation of this agent in 10 percent of the men taking spironolactone was gynecomastia or breast pain. The incidence of serious hyperkalemia (5 versus 8 percent) was small.
Spironolactone in Left Ventricular CHF
Left ventricular CHF is a problem commonly seen in family practice, with a prevalence close to 2 percent. In a typical panel of 2,500 patients, about 50 will have heart failure. In mild failure, the annual mortality is 5 to 10 percent annually; in severe cases, it increases to 30 to 40 percent annually.5
The Cooperative North Scandinavian Enalapril Survival Study (CONSENSUS)6 trial in 1987 was the first to show that ACE inhibitors could decrease mortality related to heart failure. ACE inhibitors are generally well tolerated except in patients with an elevated creatinine level (usually greater than 3 mg per dL [265 μmol per L]). The angiotensin-II receptor antagonist losartan has also been shown to decrease mortality in patients with heart failure.7
In stark contrast to previous conventional wisdom, beta blockers have been shown to reduce mortality in patients with heart failure who can tolerate them. In the Cardiac Insufficiency Bisoprolol Study (CIBIS-II),10 patients taking bisoprolol, a beta1 selective blocker, had fewer hospital admissions (NNT = 17.5) and cardiovascular deaths (NNT = 31) than the control group. All patients had NYHA class III or IV failure, were taking ACE inhibitors and diuretics, and had been clinically stable for at least six weeks.
Numerous other studies have demonstrated the benefit of beta blockers in patients with heart failure, with a 31 percent reduction in mortality overall. The benefit occurs primarily in reductions in non-sudden rather than sudden cardiac death and is similar in patients with ischemic and nonischemic cardiomyopathy.11
Carvedilol (Coreg) is the only beta blocker specifically labeled for treatment of patients with heart failure. However, studies of metoprolol, bisoprolol and propranolol have shown them to be effective in decreasing mortality, hospitalizations and hospitalizations related to heart failure. Carvedilol was found to be more effective than the other agents in patients without ischemic heart disease.12
The combination of hydralazine and isosorbide dinitrate has been shown to decrease mortality by 25 to 30 percent (Veterans Administration Cooperative Study [V-HEFT I]).13 This combination of agents has been supplanted by ACE inhibitors, which are easier to use and more effective. However, the combination would be appropriate to consider in a patient who cannot tolerate ACE inhibitors.
Cardiac Medications for Prevention
The prescribing of ACE inhibitors, beta blockers and spironolactone in patients with heart failure presents the physician with challenges because while these agents do slow long-term decline related to heart failure, they have little or no effect on symptoms. In addition, it is not clear how quickly therapy should be started, whether all three approaches should be combined at once or which drugs should be added first. Research to date suggests benefit from all of the options in patients with an ejection fraction of less than 30 percent. A prudent approach would be to begin with an ACE inhibitor (or an angiotensin-II receptor blocker) and spironolactone in most patients (Table 4), slowly adding a beta blocker after the patient is stabilized on the first two drugs.
|Drug or drug class||NNT||Outcome prevented|
|ACE inhibitors14||6||One death over one year in patients with NYHA class III and IV failure|
|100||One death over one year in patients with NYHA class I or II failure|
|Beta blockers15||23||One death over one year|
|13||One hospitalization over one year|
|Spironolactone2||9||One death over two years in patients with NYHA class IV failure|
|Hydralazine and isosorbide dinitrate13||14||One death over one year|
|Digoxin16||9||Emergency department visits or hospitalizations|
|Medications||Patients who should take them|
|ACE inhibitors||All patients with CHF|
|Spironolactone (Aldactone)||Patients with class III or IV CHF|
|Beta blockers||All patients with CHF (if tolerated)|
|Hydralazine (Apresoline)/isosorbide dinitrate (Isorem)||Patients who do not tolerate ACE inhibitors|
|Angiotensin-II receptor blockers||Unknown|
|Loop diuretics||Patients with congestive symptoms|
|Digoxin (Lanoxin)||Patients who are still symptomatic despite maximal dosages of other medications|
Specific Use of Spironolactone
Spironolactone is contraindicated in patients with anuria, acute renal insufficiency, significant renal insufficiency or hyperkalemia. Potassium supplementation should not be combined with spironolactone. Other drug interactions include errors in measurement of and an increase in the half-life of digoxin, decreased effectiveness when used with salicylates and variable effects or side effects (i.e., increased potassium) with use of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. Gynecomastia and hyponatremia can occur, along with metabolic acidosis, which is usually associated with hyperkalemia. Other side effects are rare and include drug fever, drowsiness, lack of coordination, lethargy and gastrointestinal signs and symptoms.
Dosages range from 25 to 50 mg per day in patients with heart failure, although much higher dosages are used to treat other disorders. Patients pay less than $10 per month for typical dosages. This cost compares with that of other medications used for CHF, such as $31 to $33 per month for generic metoprolol, $97 for carvedilol and $22 to $87 for low to moderate doses of ACE-inhibitor therapy.
Spironolactone absorption is increased significantly when taken with food, but the clinical significance of this effect is not known. The metabolites are excreted primarily in the urine and secondarily in the bile, with half-lives of approximately 14 to 16 hours.
One study3 has shown that spironolactone improves morbidity and mortality in patients with severe heart failure. The particular advantages of spironolactone for prevention are that it is inexpensive, is taken once daily and has relatively few side effects. This study suggests that all patients with class IV heart failure should be given a trial of spironolactone. Further research is needed to understand its usefulness in patients with less severe heart failure and whether its benefit is present in patients who are also taking beta blockers. Research is also necessary to determine which order and combinations of medications are the most beneficial in slowing the progression of this disease.
|Agent||Dosage||Comments on drug class||Comments on specific drug||Cost (generic)*|
|Benazepril (Lotensin)||20 to 40 mg daily, single dose or two divided doses||Start with low dose and titrate up||$27|
|Captopril (Capoten)||75 to 150 mg daily in three doses||Risk of neutropenia||87 (58.50 to 68)|
|Enalapril (Vasotec)||5 to 20 mg daily in divided doses||Caution with creatinine level > 3 mg per dL (265 mmol per L); do not use in pregnancy||53 (46 to 53)|
|Fosinopril (Monopril)||20 to 40 daily, single dose||29|
|Lisinopril (Zestril, Prinivil)||5 to 20 mg daily, single dose||Risk of neutropenia||28|
|Moexipril (Univasc)||7.5 to 30 daily, one hour before meals, single or two divided doses||22|
|Quinapril (Accupril)||20 to 40 mg daily in two divided doses||Can cause angioedema||66|
|Ramipril (Altace)||5 mg twice daily||67|
|Trandolapril (Mavik)||1 to 4 mg daily||24|
|Angiotensin receptor antagonists|
|Losartan (Cozaar)||25 to 100 mg daily, single or divided doses||Pregnancy class C||41|
|Valsartan (Diovan)||80 to 320 daily, single dose||Hypotension with volume depletion||41|
|Irbesartan (Avapro)||150 to 300 daily, single dose||May precipitate acute renal failure in patients with renal impairment||39|
|Candesartan (Atacand)||8 to 32 mg daily, single or two divided doses||Black patients have less response||39|
|Telmisartan (Micardis)||20 to 80 mg daily, single dose||Possible increase in liver enzymes||Increases concentration of digoxin [ corrected]||40|
|Carvedilol (Coreg)||3.125 mg twice daily for two weeks, slowly increase to maximum 25 mg twice daily (< 85 kg [187 lb]) or 50 mg twice daily (> 85 kg)||Contraindicated in patients with dizziness, bradycardia or asthma, and in patients with second- or third-degree AV block||97|
|Metoprolol (Lopressor, Toprol XL)||100 to 400 mg daily in a single dose (Toprol XL) or two divided doses (Lopressor)||Potentiates effects of calcium channel blockers||Metoprolol increases effect of phenothiazines||27 (Toprol XL) 46 (31 to 33; Lopressor)|
|Digoxin (Lanoxin)||0.125 to 0.25 mg once daily||Small therapeutic window||6 (2 to 7)|
|Furosemide (Lasix)||20 to 80 mg daily, single or two divided doses||6 (3 to 4)|
|Spironolactone (Aldactone)||25 to 50 mg daily, single dose or two divided doses||16 (2 to 6)|