TestDescriptionAdvantagesDisadvantages
Eucapnic voluntary hyperpnea testPatient hyperventilates a mixture of cold, dry air
  • Sensitive and specific

  • Less laboratory space and equipment needed

  • Need to control inspired gases and humidity

  • Need to monitor minute ventilation

  • Relatively expensive

  • Not readily available

Spirometry performed before and after hyperventilation
Field-based exercise challengeUsually performed in the environment that causes symptoms
  • Sensitive and specific for cold-weather athletes

  • Readily available

  • Minimal equipment

  • Inexpensive

  • Not standardized

  • Unable to control environment

Spirometry performed before and after exercise
Hypertonic saline testPatient is given nebulized hypertonic saline
  • Sensitive and specific

  • Less laboratory space and equipment needed

  • Not as reliable if patient is already being treated with inhaled corticosteroid

Spirometry performed before and after nebulization
Laboratory-based exercise challengeUsually performed on a treadmill or stationary bike
  • ensitive and specific

  • Standardized

  • Need to control inspired gases and humidity

  • Need to monitor heart rate and minute ventilation

  • Relatively expensive

Spirometry performed before and after exercise