TypeExamplesComments
Symptom checklists
  • Postconcussion Symptom Scale

  • Graded Symptom Checklist

  • Head Injury Scale

  • McGill Abbreviated Concussion Evaluation (ACE) postconcussion symptom scale

  • HeadMinder

  • Concussion Symptom Inventory

The most commonly used type of concussion assessment tool
Quick, easy, cost-effective tool with good sensitivity; allows athletes to self-report symptoms
Cautions: symptoms may be delayed, may not be reported, or were already present at baseline
Most checklists developed using clinical judgment; the Concussion Symptom Inventory is the only empirically derived symptom checklist
Neuropsychological tests
  • Written

    Trail Making Test

    Digit Symbol Substitution Test

    Controlled Oral Word Association Test

    Hopkins Verbal Learning Test

    Stroop Color and Word Test

  • Computer-based

    HeadMinder

    CogSport

    ImPACT

    Automated Neuropsychological Assessment Metrics

Designed to identify subtle cognitive deficits
Written tests are labor intensive and must be interpreted, whereas computer-based tests can be administered rapidly and to multiple patients simultaneously
Results best interpreted when compared with baseline data; affected by psychiatric disorders, physical symptoms, cultural factors, and motivation/effort
These tests are not validated, and no data demonstrate that they affect outcomes when used to guide return to play
There are limited baseline data in children younger than 12 years; child-specific computerized tests are under development
Postural stability testing
  • BESS (and modified version

  • SOT

Very sensitive for concussion diagnosis, but there are limited data regarding its use in monitoring recovery
SOT is the preferred test, but it is not portable; BESS is inexpensive and easy to administer on the sideline of a sporting event
Instability usually lasts three to five days after a concussion occurs
Sideline assessment tools
  • SAC

  • SCAT

  • SCAT2

A single, simple tool to assess a variety of domains in the initial concussion assessment
Often used to monitor the recovery process
SAC can be used immediately after injury to evaluate orientation, memory, concentration, and delayed recall; validated as a sideline tool for athletes junior high school–aged and older; emergency department version is validated in adults
SCAT2 combines multiple assessment tools (symptom checklist, concentration and memory tasks [Maddock's questions], SAC, BESS, and Glasgow Coma Scale); it is not validated but is widely used and the most sophisticated sideline tool available