OutcomeAbsolute changeRelative effect/resultNumber of studiesStrength of evidence
Procalcitonin point-of-care testing vs. usual care
Overall prescribing (adults only)−12% to −72%Greater reduction with procalcitonin testing1 systematic review of 4 RCTs● ● ○
Acute RTI: OR = 0.14 (95% CI, 0.09 to 0.22)
Acute bronchitis: OR = 0.15 (95% CI, 0.10 to 0.23)
Adverse consequencesNo difference in number of days of limited activity, missed work, or continuing symptoms at 28 days for upper or lower RTI in primary care1 RCT● ○ ○
No difference in hospitalizations or combined adverse effects/lack of efficacy outcome1 RCT
No difference in mortality or treatment failure at 30 days for acute bronchitis/upper RTIs in primary care or emergency department care and for upper or lower RTIs in primary care5 RCTs
Rapid streptococcal antigen point-of-care testing vs. usual care
Overall prescribing−20% to −52%Greater reduction with rapid streptococcal antigen testing3 RCTs● ● ○
Inappropriate prescribing−33%Greater reduction with rapid streptococcal antigen testing1 RCT● ○ ○
Adverse consequencesNo evidence regarding adverse consequences○ ○ ○
Rapid viral point-of-care testing (multiviral polymerase chain reaction) vs. usual care in adults
Overall prescribing−7.8%; P < .01Greater reduction with multiviral polymerase chain reaction1 RCT● ○ ○
Adverse consequencesNo evidence regarding adverse consequences○ ○ ○
C-reactive protein point-of-care testing vs. usual care
Overall prescribing−1.9% to −33.5%Greater reduction with C-reactive protein testing: RR = 0.73 (95% CI, 0.60 to 0.90)7 RCTs● ● ○
Adverse consequencesGreater reconsultation rate within 4 weeks with C-reactive protein testing3 RCTs● ● ○
Potential increased risk of hospitalization at 30 days with C-reactive protein testing7 RCTs● ○ ○
No effect on symptom resolution4 RCTs● ○ ○
Delayed vs. immediate prescribing
Overall prescribing−34% to −76%Greater reduction with delayed prescribing: OR = 0.00 to 0.126 RCTs● ● ○
Other benefitsReduced multidrug resistance for streptococcal pneumonia strains in acute otitis media with delayed prescribing1 RCT● ○ ○
Reduced diarrhea in acute otitis media with delayed prescribing2 RCTs● ○ ○
Adverse consequencesNo difference in reconsultation4 RCTs● ● ○
Reduced satisfaction with delayed prescribing5 RCTs● ● ○
Increased persistence of moderate to severe symptoms with delayed prescribing2 RCTs● ○ ○
Electronic decision support vs. usual care
Overall prescribing (systems with ≥ 50% use)−5% to −9%Greater reduction with decision support: RR = 0.73 (95% CI, 0.58 to 0.92)2 RCTs● ● ○
Inappropriate prescribing (for acute bronchitis and acute otitis media)−3% to −24%Greater reduction with decision support2 RCTs● ● ○
Adverse consequencesNo difference in health care utilization or complications1 RCT● ○ ○