This list of criteria for evaluating EMR systems has been developed for family physicians by family physicians.
Fam Pract Manag. 2002 Jan;9(1):50-51.
You’ve probably heard at least one story about a family physician who spent thousands of dollars on an electronic medical records system with all the bells and whistles only to find that it didn’t perform the necessary functions or that no one could figure out how to use it.
To help family physicians select EMR systems well suited to their practices, the AAFP recently brought together a group of physicians and EMR experts to define criteria for evaluating EMR products. The group – the Ad Hoc Committee on Electronic Medical Records – created a list of EMR features they considered to be “family-physician friendly.” They then divided the list into “basic,” “advanced” and “optional” features, recognizing that many practices initially buy basic EMR systems and later add features to increase functionality. Adding features over time simplifies the initial implementation process and spreads out the cost.
A brief excerpt from the list of criteria for evaluating EMR systems appears below. The Ad Hoc committee recommends that potential buyers do a thorough needs assessment before consulting the list. (For more information on initial planning for conversion to an EMR system, see “Selecting and Implementing an EHR.”)
CRITERIA FOR EVALUATING EMR SYSTEMS
Too often, family physicians purchase electronic medical records (EMR) systems and are disappointed with their performance. To help physicians better evaluate EMR products before they buy, the AAFP Ad Hoc Committee on Electronic Medical Records created a list of criteria that EMR systems should have in order to be “family-physician friendly.” A portion of the list appears below.
Offers structured data entry for medication, diagnoses and orders.
Allows integration of the EMR system with scheduling and billing systems.
Provides adequate system availability (around-the-clock access, if necessary).
Allows adequate response time. Buyers need to be aware of those factors that determine response time, such as the software itself, the speed of the computers and the bandwidth of the local network.
Allows user to identify and manage implementation costs. An initial capital investment is required, in addition to ongoing expenses for software maintenance and periodic upgrades.
Supports incremental implementation of additional, more advanced components.
Supports multiple office locations, including connectivity between practice sites.
Supports multiple users simultaneously.
Supports working with multiple patients quickly and safely (sequentially or concurrently).
Supports multiple user access to a single patient record, with appropriate security.
Offers online user support and technical support.
Offers adequate data protection and backups.
Offers customizable fields in various locations of the EMR to support local work flow/templates.
Allows the buyer to assess the vendor’s commitment and viability.
Affords a workable “exit strategy” should the need arise to export the data to a new system.
Allows multiple encounter records on the same patient to be open simultaneously (e.g., phone call plus office visit).
Offers evaluation and management (E/M) coding and documentation support.
Offers remote access capabilities (e.g., from home, emergency department or hospital).
Offers interface options (e.g., lab, formulary, transcription and radiology), with costs and requirements for these options clear from the outset.
Supports midlevel providers and residents in collaborative practice with physicians.
Offers patients “patient-view,” read-only Internet access to their records and the ability to request appointments, advice and refills and to learn about lab results, overdue health maintenance procedures, etc., online.
Allows patients to enter data.
Offers the scalability necessary to accommodate practice growth, additional locations and mergers.
Offers ability to exchange information between products.
Allows multiple patient records to be open simultaneously.
Supports encrypted e-mail.
Provides online access to health information.
Offers e-mail links to the Internet.
Provides dial-up support.
CLINICAL DATA REPOSITORY FEATURES
Uniquely identifies all patients by name, date of birth, medical record number, Social Security number, gender, address, etc.
Merges charts if a patient has more than one record.
Creates clinical data repository (CDR) from all discrete EMR events (e.g., diagnoses, pharmacologic and nonpharmacologic treatments, orders, results, charting and vital signs).
Allows users to query the CDR and create reports, especially for routine items such as medications, diagnoses, age and procedures.
Allows users to share data with affiliates or consultants, possibly via the Internet.
Provides security (i.e., HIPAA compliant) for sharing protected health information with affiliates or consultants, possibly via the Internet.
Allows access to and sharing of data from other systems (e.g., a hospital system).
Allows merging of family information (e.g., allows the family history for two siblings to be entered once).
Jennifer Bush is a senior associate editor for Family Practice Management.
Conflicts of interest: none reported.
Editor’s note: The list is intended to be merely a resource for physicians and is not a recommendation of any particular EMR system.
Copyright © 2002 by the American Academy of Family Physicians.
This content is owned by the AAFP. A person viewing it online may make one printout of the material and may use that printout only for his or her personal, non-commercial reference. This material may not otherwise be downloaded, copied, printed, stored, transmitted or reproduced in any medium, whether now known or later invented, except as authorized in writing by the AAFP. Contact firstname.lastname@example.org for copyright questions and/or permission requests.
Want to use this article elsewhere? Get Permissions