brand logo

Am Fam Physician. 2020;101(3):159-166

Related article: Venous Ulcers: Diagnosis and Treatment

Author disclosure: No relevant financial affiliations.

Chronic wounds are those that do not progress through a normal, orderly, and timely sequence of repair. They are common and are often incorrectly treated. The morbidity and associated costs of chronic wounds highlight the need to implement wound prevention and treatment guidelines. Common lower extremity wounds include arterial, diabetic, pressure, and venous ulcers. Physical examination alone can often guide the diagnosis. All patients with a nonhealing lower extremity ulcer should have a vascular assessment, including documentation of wound location, size, depth, drainage, and tissue type; palpation of pedal pulses; and measurement of the ankle-brachial index. Atypical nonhealing wounds should be biopsied. The mainstay of treatment is the TIME principle: tissue debridement, infection control, moisture balance, and edges of the wound. After these general measures have been addressed, treatment is specific to the ulcer type. Patients with arterial ulcers should be immediately referred to a vascular surgeon for appropriate intervention. Treatment of venous ulcers involves compression and elevation of the lower extremities, plus exercise if tolerated. Diabetic foot ulcers are managed by offloading the foot and, if necessary, treating the underlying peripheral arterial disease. Pressure ulcers are managed by offloading the affected area.

A chronic wound is one that fails to progress through a normal, orderly, and timely sequence of repair, or in which the repair process fails to restore anatomic and functional integrity after three months.1 In 2014, wound care for Medicare beneficiaries cost an estimated $28 billion to $96.8 billion.2 A 2012 German study found a 1% to 2% prevalence of chronic nonhealing wounds in the general population.3 Chronic wounds, typically diabetic ulcers, preceded 85% of amputations.4 Some chronic wounds can take decades to heal, thus contributing to secondary conditions such as depression, and can ultimately lead to isolation and family distress. The five-year mortality rate after developing a diabetic ulcer is approximately 40%5; therefore, proper diagnosis and treatment of wounds and management of comorbidities are imperative.

RecommendationSponsoring organization
Do not culture or treat clinically uninfected lower extremity wounds with systemic antibiotics.American Podiatric Medical Association
Do not use whirlpools for wound management.American Physical Therapy Association

Stages of Wound Healing

Wound healing is a complex sequence of events that begins with injury and ends with successful closure. It typically moves through four stages: hemostasis/coagulation, inflammation, proliferation, and maturation/remodeling (Table 1).6 These phases overlap as cytokines and growth factors guide the healing process. Chronic wounds most often do not progress past the inflammatory phase.

DayStagePathophysiologyOutcome
0 to 3Hemostasis/coagulationClotting, vasoconstrictionBleeding stops
1 to 25InflammationCytokines and growth factors released; vasodilation; phagocytosis (i.e., white blood cells engulf bacteria and debris); neutrophils release reactive oxygen species and proteasesRedness, swelling, warmth, and pain
1 to 25ProliferationCollagen (type III) synthesis, granulation formation, epithelialization, angiogenesis, contractionNew blood vessel growth, wound closure
20 to 365Maturation/remodelingScar remodeling (type III to I collagen)Scar strength increases to approximately 80% of original tissue

Causes of Chronic Wounds

All wounds have the potential to become chronic wounds. They are classified by etiology into four categories, each with its own typical location, depth, and appearance: arterial, diabetic, pressure, and venous ulcers7 (Table 2). To appropriately treat a chronic wound, an understanding of the pathophysiology of the wound is critical. Despite differences in etiology, chronic wounds share certain features, including excessive levels of proinflammatory cytokines, persistent infections, formation of drug-resistant microbial biofilms, and senescent cells that do not respond to reparative stimuli.8

Wound typeAppearanceAssessment
Arterial ulcerDeep; eschar; punched-out, well-demarcated borders; deep structures may be exposedPalpate pulses
Assess macrocirculation:
 Angiography
 Ankle-brachial index or toe-brachial index
 Lower extremity arterial duplex ultrasonography
 Pulse volume recording
 Segmental limb pressure
Assess microcirculation:
 Skin perfusion pressure
 Transcutaneous oximetry
Diabetic ulcerLocated on plantar aspect of foot, extensive callus formation, superficial to deepAnkle-brachial index or toe-brachial index
Bone scan if concern for osteomyelitis
Lower extremity arterial duplex ultrasonography
Magnetic resonance imaging if concern for osteomyelitis
Radiography
Transcutaneous oximetry
Wound culture
Pressure ulcerLocated over bony prominences, superficial to deepComputed tomography if indicated
Magnetic resonance imaging if concern for osteomyelitis
Nutritional support
Radiography
Wound culture
Venous ulcerShallow, no eschar; located over medial aspect of lower extremity (gaiter region)Palpate pulses
Ankle-brachial index
Doppler ultrasonography
Lower extremity arterial duplex ultrasonography
Lower extremity venous duplex ultrasonography with reflux
Transcutaneous oximetry

Assessment and Classification

Assessment of wounds should begin with a thorough physical examination. A more focused examination of the wound itself can then help guide treatment. The wound location, size, and depth; presence of drainage; and tissue type should be documented. Based on the location and appearance, most chronic wounds can be categorized by etiology, which allows for adequate workup and treatment recommendations.

Venous ulcers are the most common type of chronic wound. They are typically shallow and located on the medial supramalleolar aspect of the lower extremity (Figure 1). There may be classic signs of venous hypertension, including edema, hemosiderin staining, and lipodermatosclerosis. Workup should include assessment of arterial status with the ankle-brachial index (ABI) and palpation of pulses to rule out mixed arterial and venous disease and to ensure adequate perfusion before compression.9 If necessary, further workup with venous duplex ultrasonography with reflux and/or arterial duplex ultrasonography will help with the diagnosis.

Arterial ulcers are typically located on the distal extremities and may be deep, with tendon or bone exposed (Figure 2). As with venous ulcers, the initial workup should include ABI measurement and palpation of pulses. An ABI less than 0.8 may be a sign of arterial disease, and an ABI greater than 1.2 is consistent with noncompressible vessels. Both require further vascular assessment, which may include arterial Doppler/duplex ultrasonography, segmental limb pressures, pulse volume recording, skin perfusion pressure, or transcutaneous oximetry.10 Referral to a specialist should be considered if vascular test results suggest poor perfusion.

Diabetic ulcers are the most common cause of lower extremity amputation. Early intervention and management are essential given the high mortality rate after amputation.5 Diabetic foot ulcers are caused by a combination of underlying neuropathy, peripheral arterial disease, and structural deformities that cause increased pressure on affected areas of the foot.11 Diabetes mellitus affects sensory, motor, and autonomic nerve function. The combined effects result in structural deformities of the foot; dry, poorly hydrated integument; and an inability to detect pain and repetitive injury. Diabetes also causes higher rates of atherosclerotic disease.12 Diabetic ulcers are typically located on the toes or the plantar aspect of the metatarsal heads (Figure 3). They may have the characteristic crater-like appearance, be covered in eschar or necrotic tissue at the wound bed, and have exposed deep structures including tendon and bone. These ulcers can be shallow or deep and are usually surrounded by a thick ring of callus. Workup should include palpation of pedal pulses, ABI measurement,12 and assessment for neuropathy with Semmes-Weinstein monofilament.13 Imaging is often required to rule out deeper infection such as osteomyelitis. Patients with diabetes often have calcified, noncompressible arteries that result in an abnormally high ABI. A more reliable test in these patients is the toe-brachial index because the toe arteries rarely calcify.14

The term pressure ulcer is preferred over bedsore, decubitus ulcer, or pressure sore. A pressure ulcer is a localized injury to the skin or underlying tissue—usually over a bony prominence such as the sacrum, coccyx, hip, or heel—that results from pressure in combination with shear force (Figure 4). Pressure ulcers can also be caused by devices such as nasal cannulas, nasogastric tubes, and casts or splints. Risk-assessment tools such as the Braden scale 15 can help minimize pressure ulcers by identifying high-risk patients. These ulcers are managed according to guidelines from the National Pressure Ulcer Advisory Panel, which classifies them into six stages based on the extent of tissue damage. Assessment may include a workup for infection, imaging to rule out deeper infection, and nutritional assessment.

When assessing a chronic wound for infection, physicians should be aware that chronic infected wounds have different signs and symptoms than acute infected wounds. Typical signs of infection such as erythema, edema, pain, and fever are not always present. Two mnemonics are used to identify chronic wounds with infectious processes:

  • NERDS (for wounds with biofilm or critical colonization): nonhealing, exudative, red and bleeds easily, debris, and smell. Sensitivity is 73% and specificity is 80.5% when three criteria are present.16

  • STONEES (for infection): size increasing, temperature increased, os (probes to or exposed bone), new areas of breakdown, exudative, erythema/edema, and smell. Sensitivity is 90% and specificity is 69.4% when three criteria are present.16

Biopsy with quantitative processing is the best method of wound culture; a result of more than 100,000 colony-forming units is considered positive. Other options include the Levine and Z techniques. The Levine technique is superior, with several studies showing higher sensitivity and specificity compared with the Z technique.17 The Levine technique consists of debriding superficial necrotic tissue, then applying pressure with a swab while rolling it over 1 cm2 for five seconds to obtain fluid from deeper in the wound. In the Z technique, the handle of a swab is rotated between the fingers in a zig-zag fashion across the wound without touching the wound edge.

A chronic wound that does not respond to appropriate care may be an atypical wound. Atypical wounds are located in abnormal locations, have an abnormal appearance, and do not heal after three to six months of standard wound care. Atypical wounds have inflammatory, infectious, vasculopathic, metabolic, genetic, malignant, or external etiologies (e.g., calciphylaxis, pyoderma gangrenosum, vasculitis, autoimmune disease). Physicians should perform a biopsy for further evaluation in patients with suspected atypical wounds.18 Referral to a wound care specialist, dermatologist, or rheumatologist may also be indicated.

Treatment

Initially, all chronic wounds should be treated according to the TIME principle: tissue debridement (in all cases except arterial ulcers), infection control, moisture balance, and edges of the wound.19 After these general measures are addressed, the ulcer must be correctly diagnosed and classified so that appropriate care can be provided.

Debridement is the removal of dead cells and is an essential part of wound care. It is the first-line treatment for chronic wounds. A 2005 study showed that healing of chronic wounds is twice as likely with aggressive debridement.20 Another study of 154,664 patients with 312,744 wounds showed that consistent debridement at intervals of one week or less resulted in significantly faster healing and a 70.8% overall healing rate.21

In addition to removing dead cells and tissue, debridement of biofilm—multicellular communities held together by a self-produced extracellular matrix that can halt the healing process22—is a key factor in wound healing. The National Institutes of Health reports that 80% of wound infections are due to biofilm.23 Biofilm is invisible to the naked eye, and detection with different techniques is currently being investigated.24 Without destruction of biofilm, wound healing can stall during the inflammatory phase.25

There are several different types of debridement: surgical, autolytic, enzymatic, and biologic. Surgical debridement is used most often, but other methods may be appropriate depending on the type of wound. Infection is usually controlled with topical agents, including dressings with silver, polyhexamethylene biguanide, and cadexomer iodine. Antimicrobial washes may also be beneficial if biofilm is suspected. If cellulitis or signs of systemic infection are present, oral antibiotics may also be indicated.

Moisture balance is an essential part of wound care. Chronic wounds should never be exposed to air to “dry out,” as is often recommended. Moist wounds heal more quickly and have less risk of infection.26 If a wound appears dry, moisture needs to be added; this is accomplished by choosing an appropriate dressing (Table 3).6 Conversely, if a wound is draining, the drainage needs to be controlled and kept off of the periwound. The proper dressing should hold the moisture on the wound bed to prevent desiccation.

Wound appearanceType of dressing
DrainingCalcium alginate
Collagen
Composite
Foam
Hydrocolloid (for mild to moderate drainage)
Infected/inflamedCadexomer iodine
Polyhexamethylene biguanide
Silver impregnated
NecroticCollagenase (enzymatic debridement)
Honey impregnated (autolytic debridement)
Hydrocolloid (autolytic debridement)
Maggots (biologic debridement)
Nondraining/dryCollagen gel
Composite
Hydrocolloid
Hydrogel
Transparent film

Wound edges must be free from undermining. If edges are rolled, they should be excised. This allows for epithelialization, which is the clearest sign the wound is healing.27

TREATMENT BY WOUND ETIOLOGY

Venous Ulcers. Venous hypertension due to incompetent veins or venous obstruction distends the superficial veins, causing wall damage, exudation of fluid into the interstitial space, and edema of venous insufficiency. Treatment consists of exercise, which lowers venous pressures28; elevation of lower extremities; and adequate compression—usually 30 to 40 mm Hg—to improve venous return29 after vascular status has been proven adequate(Table 4).29,30 Patients may benefit from statin therapy for its vasoactive and anti-inflammatory effects.30 Early endovenous ablation may also be beneficial.31

TreatmentComments
Compression29 After vascular evaluation, compress 30 to 40 mm Hg as tolerated (contraindicated if ankle-brachial index < 0.6)
Stockings and wraps:
 Long stretch (> 140% extensibility)
 Short stretch (≤ 60% extensibility)
 Zinc oxide compression bandage (Unna Boot)
ElevationElevation above level of the heart at rest
ExerciseWalking activates calf muscle pump
Simvastatin (Zocor)30 Vasoactive and anti-inflammatory properties in addition to lipid-lowering properties
Clinically significant improvement in healing time and healing rates
Wound careTIME principle: tissue debridement, infection control, moisture balance, and edges of the wound

Arterial Ulcers. The first step in the management of arterial ulcers is treating the underlying cause, which may include vascular bypass, stents, or dilation by a vascular surgeon (Table 5). The goals of wound care before adequate perfusion is obtained are to prevent infection and minimize debridement. After vascular intervention, the TIME principle should be used.

TreatmentComments
ExercisePlanned graduated walking program
InterventionAngiography, angioplasty, or stents
Vascular bypass surgery
Wound careTIME principle: tissue debridement, infection control, moisture balance, and edges of the wound
Apply emollients to keep skin pliable
Vascular evaluation
Healable (adequate perfusion):
 TIME
 Maintain moisture balance
Nonhealable (ischemia):
 Control infection
 Limit debridement
 Maintain moisture balance

Diabetic Ulcers. Treatment of diabetic ulcers begins with optimal control of blood glucose levels. Most patients with diabetic foot ulcers also have underlying peripheral arterial disease, which requires evaluation. The thick callus that typically surrounds diabetic foot ulcers requires surgical debridement. The preferred treatment approach for diabetic foot ulcers is offloading the foot to remove pressure from the affected area32,33 (Table 63234 ). This can be accomplished with certain shoes or other devices, but the recommended method is a total contact cast.32,33 Some diabetic foot ulcers will benefit from hyperbaric oxygen therapy.35

TreatmentComments
CompressionEvaluate for peripheral arterial disease
Compress 30 to 40 mm Hg as tolerated if edema is present and perfusion
is adequate
ExercisePlanned graduated walking program
Hyperbaric oxygen therapy34 Significantly improves healing rate and quality of life
Offloading32,33 Nonremovable offloading:
 Plaster/fiberglass total contact cast
 Roll-on total contact cast (similar to fiberglass)
 Total contact cast with removable boot
Removable offloading:
 Aircast pneumatic walker
 CAM walker
 Charcot restraint orthotic walker
 Half-wedge shoe
 Heel relief shoe
Wound careTIME principle: tissue debridement, infection control, moisture balance, and edges of the wound

Pressure Ulcers. Localized treatment for pressure ulcers follows the same TIME principle used for all chronic wounds, but has a greater emphasis on pressure redistribution, offloading, and microclimate control6,36 (Table 76 ). A common mistake is the recommendation of donut-style cushions for offloading. These should not be used because they impede blood flow to the area and can actually worsen existing ulcers or increase the risk of developing a new ulcer.37

ManagementComments
Appropriate movement of patientDo not drag patient
MicroclimateControl moisture
Keep skin clean and dry
Use barrier creams
Wash with pH-balanced skin cleanser and water
Nutritional support6 Ensure adequate hydration
Increase protein intake to 1.5 g per kg body weight
Supplements:
 Vitamin A
 Vitamin C
 Zinc
OffloadingChange positions every one to two hours to limit pressure on affected area
Small shifts in weight every 15 minutes
Pressure redistributionAir- or fluid-filled mattress
Air- or gel-filled seat cushions
No donut-style cushions
Risk assessmentBraden scale
Wound careTIME principle: tissue debridement, infection control, moisture balance, and edges of the wound based on wound stage

Data Sources: An initial PubMed search was performed using the key terms chronic wounds, diabetic foot ulcers, venous ulcers, arterial ulcers, and pressure ulcers. The search included clinical trials, systematic reviews, randomized controlled trials, and meta-analyses published since 1990. Several other searches were done using the Cochrane database, the Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement, the National Guideline Clearinghouse, and the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality clinical guidelines and evidence reports. The Essential Evidence summary provided by AFP was also used, as were several landmark articles in wound care and guidelines from the major societies involved with wound care. Search date: May 2018.

The authors thank Jill Stoelzl, RN, CWOCN, and Elizabeth Shimer Bowers for editing and writing assistance.

Continue Reading


More in AFP

More in Pubmed

Copyright © 2020 by the American Academy of Family Physicians.

This content is owned by the AAFP. A person viewing it online may make one printout of the material and may use that printout only for his or her personal, non-commercial reference. This material may not otherwise be downloaded, copied, printed, stored, transmitted or reproduced in any medium, whether now known or later invented, except as authorized in writing by the AAFP.  See permissions for copyright questions and/or permission requests.