By taking these five steps, physicians can start changing a culture of medicine that prizes stoic perfectionism and stigmatizes asking for help.
Rates of alcohol use disorder, depression, and suicidal ideation are all greater among physicians and medical trainees than the general population,1–12 despite education levels and financial resources that insulate physicians from some risk factors such as poverty and lack of access to mental health care. Many of these problems are driven by a medical culture that prizes stoic perfectionism and stigmatizes asking for help.
This article seeks to quantify the problem of physician substance use disorder, depression, and suicide, and then provide steps we can all take to reduce the incidence of these conditions for ourselves and our colleagues.
KEY POINTS
- Physicians and medical trainees have higher rates of alcohol use disorder, depression, and suicidal ideation than the general population.
- The perfectionist culture of medicine, as well as fears about losing licenses or credentials, may prevent physicians from seeking mental health care.
- By speaking up about their own struggles and looking after colleagues, physicians can start to change the culture and increase use of the many mental health care resources available to them.
QUANTIFYING THE PROBLEM
Recent studies suggest that while the misuse of illicit drugs is less common among physicians and medical trainees than the general population, alcohol use disorder is more common.1 About 10% of the U.S. population has alcohol use disorder,2 while surveys indicate the rate may be 32% among medical students3 and 13% among emergency medicine residents.4 Debt and financial instability among students and residents may lead to stress and maladaptive coping through alcohol use.3,4 But the problem persists after training, with both male physicians (13%) and female physicians (21%)1 experiencing higher alcohol use disorder rates than the general population. The sex discrepancy may be related to the disproportionate effect on females of certain risk factors for alcohol use, such as work-home conflict (see “Risk factors for alcohol and substance use disorders among medical trainees and physicians”).5
RISK FACTORS FOR ALCOHOL AND SUBSTANCE USE DISORDERS AMONG MEDICAL TRAINEES AND PHYSICIANS
Various studies have found the following risk factors associated with alcohol and substance use disorder among physicians and medical trainees.1,3,5
- Depression
- Burnout
- Suicidal ideation
- Career dissatisfaction
- Female sex
- Medical errors
- Debt
- Work-home conflict
Read the full article
Get immediate access, anytime, anywhere.
Choose a single article, issue, or full-access subscription.
Earn up to 5 CME credits per issue.
