Gender pay equity: What are we teaching future family physicians?

By Astrud Villareal, MD, FAAFP
November 17, 2026
Four women including Astrud Villareal, MD, FAAFP, pose for a selfie at the beach.

UT Southwestern Family Medicine Residency Associate Program Director Astrud Villareal, MD, FAAFP, right, poses with residents Areeba Mubarik, MD; Sandra Chang, MD; and Priscilla Lee Kha, DO, on the beach during a break from the 2025 Family Medicine Experience in Anaheim, Calif.

One of the things I love about academic family medicine is helping residents imagine what comes next. We spend years helping them grow into physicians who can care for patients, lead teams and serve their communities. Along the way, we hope they find a place where they can build a meaningful career and feel that they belong.

They learn what that future might look like by watching us. They notice how we care for patients and support one another. They also see whose work gets recognized, who has opportunities to lead and whether the values we teach show up in the way we treat our colleagues.

Gender pay equity starts with academic leadership

In her recent AAFP blog, Jessica Triche, MD, shared how she discovered a pay disparity and worked to change her organization’s compensation model. I appreciated her willingness to speak up, even when doing so was uncomfortable.

Her story also made me think about our responsibility as academic leaders to find and address these differences before a colleague has to fight to be heard. That responsibility matters to the people working alongside us today and to the learners deciding whether they can see themselves in our shoes.

Women make up the majority of AAFP student and resident members, accounting for 60% and 58%, respectively. When we tell them there is a place for them in family medicine, I want that invitation to mean something. I want them to know that their work will be valued fairly, that they will have opportunities to grow and that they can build a career they want to stay in. How we compensate our faculty is part of keeping that promise.

How the gender pay gap affects academic physicians

There is still work to do. A 2022 study​ using salary data from 54,479 academic physicians found lower starting salaries for women in 42 of 45 subspecialties. Its modeling suggested that equalizing starting salaries would address most of the difference in early career earning potential. That first offer can have consequences well beyond the first year on faculty.

As educators, we can help residents understand contracts, compensation benchmarks and negotiation. But I also want them to enter organizations that take responsibility for making fair offers in the first place. Getting paid equitably should not depend on whether a new graduate knows the right question to ask.

We also need to look carefully at the work we ask faculty to do. In academic family medicine, a day can include seeing patients, helping a resident work through a difficult encounter, preparing a teaching session and sorting out a clinic problem. Each of those responsibilities matters. When we rely on someone to do that work, we need to account for the time and support it requires.

Even clinical productivity requires a closer look. A 2020 study of primary care physicians​ found that women generated approximately 11% less office-visit revenue while spending more total observed time with patients over the year. They spent about 16% more time per visit, after adjustment for physician, patient and visit characteristics. Revenue was not a complete measure of the time devoted to care.

That matters in a specialty built on relationships. We teach residents to listen, understand their patients’ lives and work through complicated concerns together. We should be willing to ask whether our compensation models support the care we are teaching them to provide.

Why fair compensation matters for faculty retention

There is a human cost to feeling undervalued, too. It can be difficult to keep giving your time and energy to a place when you question whether your contributions are recognized fairly. For a faculty member already balancing patient care, teaching and other responsibilities, that concern can add to the strain.

Research gives us reason to pay attention. In a national survey of 2,263 physicians​, those who felt their compensation was fair reported greater work satisfaction and a lower intention to leave their practice. In a separate survey of 410 women faculty in departments of medicine​, perceived fair compensation and equitable access to resources were associated with intent to stay at their institution. Work-life integration, family leave policies, mentorship and women role models also mattered.

These studies do not tell us that pay inequity alone causes burnout or leads women to leave medicine. They do remind us that fairness is part of the environment in which physicians decide whether they can continue doing the work they love. A decision to leave one institution is also different from leaving academic medicine or clinical practice altogether.

When a faculty colleague leaves, that loss is felt in many places. A patient may have to start over with a new physician. A resident loses a trusted teacher or adviser. Colleagues take on additional work. Over time, losing experienced faculty can also affect our ability to train the next generation. Keeping good physicians in academic family medicine matters to the people we teach and the communities we serve.

Building more equitable faculty compensation models

In my own academic setting, we are starting with more open conversations about the additional responsibilities faculty take on. What does a role involve? Is there protected time? Is there additional compensation? We are also working toward clear job descriptions so that the full scope of the work is visible, including teaching, advising, administrative responsibilities and clinic leadership. We are having these conversations with colleagues at other institutions as well to understand how similar roles are defined and supported. These are steps toward understanding where differences exist and asking how we can better recognize and support the work our colleagues do.

Those conversations need to be followed by institutional action. Regular reviews of total compensation, clear criteria for starting salaries and advancement, and a process for correcting unexplained differences can help. That means looking at incentives and leadership stipends as well as base pay, and examining how gender intersects with race and ethnicity. Faculty should understand how decisions are made and know that when they raise a concern, someone will listen and follow through.

Advancing gender pay equity in family medicine

We ask our residents to notice when something is unfair and to advocate for their patients. We owe our colleagues that same care and willingness to act.

I had the opportunity to be part of an AAFP group that worked on the new Gender Equity in Family Medicine Compensation policy statement. Being part of that work has reinforced for me that we each have a role in moving this conversation forward. If you are in a position to advocate for fair compensation, use that opportunity. Ask questions, bring attention to work that may be overlooked and speak up for colleagues whose contributions deserve recognition.

You do not have to be the person making the final decision to help shape it. Your voice matters. I want our students and residents to look at the faculty around them and think, “I can see a future for myself here.” Paying people fairly and recognizing the work they do are part of making that future possible.

Astrud Villareal, MD, FAAFP, is an assistant professor in the Department of Family and Community Medicine​ at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center and an associate program director of the UT Southwestern Family Medicine Residency. She also is a member of the AAFP Commission on Membership and Member Services.

Disclaimer

The opinions and views expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent or reflect the opinions and views of the American Academy of Family Physicians. This blog is not intended to provide medical, financial, or legal advice.

Latest blog posts

Latest CME and events